CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
A number of other decisions
are also particularly relevant to the
cybercrime investigative context. In
the European system, the voluntary
supply of telephone records by a
telecommunications service provider
to law enforcement, for example, has
been found to be incompatible with
the right to privacy in the absence of
specific legal rules.97 Similarly, in the
Americas, the recording of telephone
conversations authorized by mere
judicial annotation and not linked
with an established investigation has
been found to violate the right to
privacy.98
Legislative safeguards for investigative measures
UN-HRC Communication CCPR/C/82/D/903/1999
The interception and recording of data traffic on the written
authorization of an investigating judge, in the context of a
preliminary judicial investigation into the involvement of an
individual in a criminal organization, was found not to violate the
right to privacy. The Committee highlighted that authorizing
legislation detailed the precise circumstances in which interference
may be permitted and that the interference was proportionate and
necessary to achieve the legitimate purpose of combating crime.
ECtHR Application No. 2872/02
The lack of an effective criminal investigation due to the absence of
an explicit legal provision authorizing the disclosure of
telecommunications data in the case of an online content offence
was found to be incompatible with the positive obligations of the
right to privacy. The Court highlighted that the victim had not been
afforded effective protection.
It is very likely that existing ECtHR Application No. 62540/00
principles from such cases will be The provisions of a national law regulating secret surveillance
applied in future cybercrime cases. measures were found to be incompatible with the right to privacy.
The Court emphasized that the law did not provide for any review
The search of a computer system for of implementation of measures by an external body or official; that
files, or the covert monitoring of it did not set out procedures for preservation of the integrity and
emails or IP traffic, for example, confidentiality of evidence obtained, or procedures for its
shows close parallels with traditional destruction; and that overall control of surveillance rested with a
member of the executive, rather than an independent body.
physical search and wiretaps. The
actions of ISPs in delivering data to Investigative measures in practice
law enforcement authorities (whether IACtHR Escher Judgment of 6 July 2009
under an informal cooperation The recording of telephone conversations by the state and their
agreement, or pursuant to a warrant, subsequent dissemination without full respect for national legal
subpoena or other legal order) are requirements was found to be incompatible with the right to
privacy. The Court emphasized that the monitoring petition was
equivalent
to
those
of
not linked to an established police investigation or criminal
telecommunication providers. In proceeding. The Court also highlighted that the interception was
particular,
the
potential
for authorized by a mere judicial annotation that did not demonstrate
cybercrime investigations to access a reasoning, procedural requirements, or duration of the measure.
wide range of personal information – ECtHR Application No. 13710/88
including emails, VOIP calls, internet A search impinging on the profession secrecy of a lawyer’s office
browsing histories, and photographs under a broad warrant authorizing search for and seizure of
– presents a particularly high level of ‘documents’ was found to be incompatible with the right to
privacy. The Court held that the measure was not proportionate to
potential intrusiveness. In many cases,
its aims.
such as when records are requested
from an ISP or real-time data
collection is authorized, the subject of the investigation will likely be unaware of the fact of the
investigation and of the nature and extent of data gathered, thus engaging human rights
jurisprudence on secret surveillance.99 In such circumstances – due, not least, to resultant
vulnerabilities to misuse – regional human rights tribunals have urged particular caution.100
97
98
99
100
ECtHR Application No. 8691/79
IACtHR Escher Judgement of 6 July 2009.
In addition to cases in the table, see also ECtHR Application No. 54934/00.
The ECtHR holds, for instance, that ‘Powers of secret surveillance of citizens, characterising as they do the police state, are tolerable under the
139
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents