electronic communications potentially relevant to a criminal act may include gigabytes of
photographs, videos, emails, chat logs and system data. Locating relevant information within this
data can be extremely time-consuming. The variety of possible file formats, operating systems,
application software, and hardware particulars also serves to complicate the process of identifying
relevant information.
Computer artefacts can be easily modified, overwritten or deleted, thus posing challenges
where sources of digital information must be authenticated and verified.2 Evidence rules vary
considerably between jurisdictions, even amongst countries with similar legal traditions. In general
terms, however, legal systems of the common law tradition tend to have defined rules as to the
admissibility of evidence. In legal systems of the civil law tradition, in which professional judges
retain a high degree of control over the court proceedings, admissibility of evidence may be flexible,
although the weighing of evidence (including ascertaining its credibility and authenticity) can also
obey a comprehensive set of rules.3
In many legal systems, the quality of procedures applied to maintain the integrity of digital
information from the moment of creation to the point of introduction in court must be
demonstrated by the proponent of the evidence. The integrity and authenticity of digital information
has a direct bearing on the weight of evidence, in terms of its reliability and trustworthiness. The
party seeking to introduce evidence must usually demonstrate evidence continuity, or ‘chain-ofcustody,’ so that it can be proved that the evidence has not been tampered with or otherwise altered.
Evidence continuity is typically a question of fact and the chain-of-custody process is the
mechanism applied for maintaining and documenting the chronological history of the evidence as it
moves from one place to another.4
In the case of digital information, evidence continuity must be maintained for both the
physical device housing the data (when received or seized), and the stored data residing on the device.5
As such, the party offering the evidence must demonstrate that: (i) the digital information obtained
from the device is a true and accurate representation of the original data contained on the device
(authenticity); and (ii) that the device and data sought to be introduced as evidence is the same as
that which was originally discovered and subsequently taken into custody (integrity). The objective is
to show that the device is what it is purported to be and that the digital information is trustworthy,
and has not been tampered with or altered.6
The reliability of computer-generated and computer-stored information has also been
challenged on the basis of security vulnerabilities in operating systems and programs that could give
rise to threats to the integrity of the digital information. The susceptibility of digital information to
manipulation has been considered by courts when introducing electronic evidence, with emphasis
on ‘the need to show the accuracy of the computer in the retention and retrieval of the information at issue.’7 The
admissibility of computer-generated information (such as log file records) detailing the activities on a
2
3
4
5
6
7
See for example United States v Whitaker, 127 F3d 595, 602 (7th Cir. 1997).
See Jackson, J.D., and Summers, S.J., 2012. The Internationalisation of Criminal Evidence: Beyond the Common Law and Civil Law Traditions.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Casey, E., 2011. Digital Evidence and Computer Crime: Forensic Science, Computers and the Internet. New York: Elsevier.
U.S. Department of Justice, 2007. Digital Evidence in the Courtroom: A Guide for Law Enforcement and Prosecutors. National Institute of
Justice, p.16.
Marcella Jr., A.J., Greenfield, R.S., (eds.), 2002. Cyber Forensics: A Field Manual for Collecting, Examining, and Preserving Evidence of
Computer Crimes, 2nd edn. Boca Raton: CRC Press, p.136.
Re Vee Vinhnee, Debtor American Express Travel Related Services Company, Inc v Vee Vinhnee 336 BR 437 (9th Cir BAP, December 16,
2006), p.18.
158
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents