CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
computer, network, or other device may be open to challenge when the system generating the
information does not have robust security controls. 8
In addition to demonstrating authenticity and integrity of evidence, challenges to the use of
electronic evidence arise, in some jurisdictions, from the application of particular evidential rules. It
may need to be demonstrated, for example, that electronic evidence falls within particular exceptions
to a general prohibition on ‘hearsay’ evidence, 9 or that a ‘print-out’ of computer data satisfies
requirements such as a ‘best evidence’ rule. 10 National approaches to such issues reported through
the Study questionnaire are addressed in this Chapter.
Digital forensics
Many forms of electronic evidence may be comparatively straightforward, such as a printout
of a readily available email sent by a perpetrator, or IP connection logs reported directly by an
internet service provider. Other forms, on the other hand, may require sophisticated techniques in
order to recover traces of
activity or data from
computers and networks
Forensics scenario: Evidence of computer fraud from an Internet café
that
can
provide
Scenario: A fraud has been attempted via email. Police gain evidence that the emails in
evidence of criminal
question may have been sent from a desktop computer in a local internet café
behaviour.
Digital
A typical internet café setup resembles, in many ways, a home network
forensics is the branch of
environment. It is likely to contain multiple laptop or desktop computers
connecting over a combination of wireless and wired network devices. For
forensic
science
the purposes of billing usage of computers, a cybercafé may require user
concerned with the
identification; in several jurisdictions this is mandatory, and provides an audit
recovery
and
trail to link an individual to a particular computer at a given time. It may also
be possible to identify an individual using a computer at a given time through
investigation of material
footage from security cameras.
found in digital and
If an investigation occurs swiftly enough, or if prior knowledge of activities is
computer systems. To
given, then forensic investigators may be in a position to gain physical access
to the computer and to conduct a standard investigation. This process is
discover such traces,
complicated by the public nature of the device, which consequently contains
digital forensics experts
traces of many users' activity.
take advantage of the
An internet café, regularly handling more users and traffic than a home
network, is likely to have additional network devices such as proxy servers
tendency of computers
that keep copies of commonly-requested web pages in order to speed up
to store, log and record
traffic; and firewall hardware for security. These devices may be analysed for
traces of network activity linked to the suspicious activities of the user.
details of almost every
action that they, and
hence
their
users,
perform.
Information stored on electronic devices, including computers and mobile phones, is
volatile and easily altered or corrupted in investigations. At the same time, such information is easily
duplicated. A crucial first step in many digital forensics investigations is therefore to create an
8
9
10
Chaikin, D., 2006. Network investigations of cyber attacks: the limits of digital evidence. Crime, Law and Social Change, 46(4-5):239256, 249.
Hearsay is often defined as ‘evidence given of a statement made on some other occasion, when intended as evidence of the truth of what was asserted’
(Halbury’s Laws, Vol. 17). Certain types of digital evidence may strictly constitute hearsay, but could be admitted under exceptions
such as ‘business records.’ See Thomson, L.L., 2011. Admissibility of Electronic Documentation as Evidence in U.S. Courts.
Appendix IX.B.1, Center for Research Libraries, Human Rights Electronic Evidence Study.
As a general principle, courts are entitled to the best evidence that is available. If a best evidence rule is applied, copies of an
original may not be admissible as evidence unless it can be demonstrated that the original is unavailable due to destruction or other
circumstances. The printout of information located on a computer or other storage device might not technically be regarded as
‘original.’ In some jurisdictions, however, the best evidence rule does not operate to exclude printouts, provided that the printout
accurately reflects the actual data. See, for example, Doe v United States, 805 F. Supp. 1513, 1517 (D. Hawaii. 1992); and Laughner v
State, 769 N.E.2d 1147, 159 (Ind. Ct. App. 2002).
159
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents