variety of software programs, engage technical expertise, or refer the potential evidence to their
forensics labs or specialized personnel for attempted decryption. One country mentioned using
‘certified professionals and certified software’29 in decryption efforts. Other countries referred to the
possibility of arresting a suspect ‘while the machines are open, up, and running’30 when data may be in an
unencrypted state.
In addition to the challenges presented to digital forensics by encryption technology,
perpetrators may also make use of ‘steganography’ (information ‘hiding’). This involves concealing
information or communications within otherwise innocent files, such as graphic images, documents,
audio samples or applications. Media files are ideal hosts for steganography as they are typically large
and will not immediately arouse suspicion. From a forensic perspective, identification of hidden data
may be achieved by comparing suspect files or data streams with known originals. A number of
responding countries highlighted a general increase in use of obfuscation techniques and encryption.
One country in the Americas reported ‘criminal organizations try to make investigations difficult by storing
criminal data in foreign servers or in cloud storage systems, and use cryptography and other data obfuscation
techniques.’31
Increasing use of cloud computing presents particular challenges for digital forensics.
Information stored remotely by perpetrators in cloud services may become visible to investigators
during a search or forensic examination – such as when live internet sessions are encountered on
running computers, or through remote services available on seized mobile devices. In addition to
legal considerations associated with direct law enforcement access to extraterritorial data (examined
in Chapter Seven (International cooperation)), cloud data storage complicates the forensic process
of identification, collection, and analysis of electronically stored information.32 The possibility that
one cloud user may gain access to another’s data also introduces the possibility of further challenges
to data authenticity.
Faced with such challenges, responding countries reported that a variety of techniques are
used to ensure that the integrity of electronic evidence collected through digital forensics is
maintained. Countries referred, for example, to the use of forensic imaging; the use of sworn
statements attesting to the authenticity of data; forensic hash values; the use of write blockers;
capture of internet data through screen shots; systematic labelling, documentation, packaging and
transportation methods; and sealing of forensic images recorded on optical disk.33 With respect to
standards and guidelines for forensic investigations, a few countries referred to the Association of
Chief Police Officers’ Good Practice Guide for Computer-Based Electronic Evidence.34
Countries also reported a number of practices for storing electronic evidence in order to
protect against degradation and damage. These included the use of multiple clone copies from a
single master copy; storage of computer data within a designated IT-forensic network under
restricted access; the use of humidity, temperature, and electromagnetic radiation controlled
29
30
31
32
33
34
notice to disclose can result in a term of imprisonment and/or fine upon conviction. Similarly, the Cybercrime Act 2001 in one
country in Oceania allows a magistrate to make an order requiring a specified person to provide any information or assistance that
is reasonable and necessary to allow a law enforcement officer to access data held in or accessible from a computer.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q85.
Reilly, D., Wren, C., and Berry, T., 2011. Cloud computing: Pros and Cons for Computer Forensic Investigators. International Journal
Multimedia and Image Processing, 1(1):26-34, 33.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q111.
See http://www.met.police.uk/pceu/documents/ACPOguidelinescomputerevidence.pdf
164
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents