CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE facilities; the use of safes; the use of anti-static devices; use of supervised evidence lockers; and use of sealed bags.35 In addition to law Figure 6.3: Sufficiency of resources to handle and enforcement capacity for analyse electronic evidence digital forensics, it is also important that prosecutors have Europe sufficient resources to handle (n=13) and analyse electronic Asia & Oceania evidence. Electronic evidence (n=13) that is not presented at trial Yes can play no role in helping just Americas (n=11) No adjudication of the accused. Country responses show that Africa prosecutors typically report a (n=6) lower level of resources for 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% handling electronic evidence 36 than for law enforcement. Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q149. (n=44) Some countries, for example, commented that prosecutors often experience difficulty in making sense of electronic evidence and require the assistance of other professionals to identify trends and give data meaning.37 None of the African respondents reported that prosecutor resources for electronic evidence were sufficient – highlighting an urgent area for focus in technical assistance and support. Electronic evidence in criminal proceedings More than 85 per cent of responding countries reported that electronic evidence was admissible in criminal proceedings.38 A small number of countries – predominantly in Africa and Asia – stated, however, that Figure 6.4: Electronic evidence admissible in criminal electronic evidence was not proceedings admissible. One country in 14% Africa, for example, held that Yes, such evidence is electronic evidence was ‘Not always admissible 28% defined in our law and hence Yes, admissible only when inadmissible.’39 Where this is the 14% data integrity can be demonstrated case, a serious obstacle to the Yes, admissible only at the successful prosecution of discretion of the court cybercrime and crimes involving Yes, admissible only when electronic evidence exists. For the correct authorization those countries where electronic procedure was followed 19% 25% evidence is generally admissible No in criminal proceedings, such Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q144. (n=43) admissibility is subject to conditions, such as the 35 36 37 38 39 Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q111. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q149. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q149. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q144. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q143. 165

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents