demonstrated integrity of the
data, the discretion of the
court,
or
authorization
procedures, in around 70 per
cent of countries.40
Figure 6.5: Legal distinction between electronic evidence and
physical evidence
Europe
n=(14)
Asia & Oceania
(n=18)
Despite
general
Yes
Americas
recognition of electronic
(n=11)
No
evidence in national courts,
Africa
one country reported not
(n=7)
recognizing
electronic
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
evidence from outside of its
Source: Study cybercri me questionnaire. Q143. (n=50)
jurisdiction.41 In the case of a
transnational crime such as cybercrime, such a restriction can impact upon the possibility for
successful prosecutions. A number of countries reported that admissibility issues for extraterritorial
electronic evidence often turn on whether mutual legal assistance procedures have been properly
followed. One country, for example, emphasized that ‘foreign evidence adduced in criminal proceedings must
be in the form of testimony and any exhibit annexed to such a testimony…; testimony must be taken under oath or
affirmation, under such caution or admonition as would be accepted by the court in the foreign country, or under an
obligation to tell the truth imposed, whether expressly or by implication, by or under a law of the foreign country, and
the testimony must purport to be signed or certified by a judge, magistrate or officer.’42 In many jurisdictions, such
requirements frequently prevent extraterritorial electronic evidence obtained through informal policeto-police channels from being relied upon in criminal trials.
The greater number of countries that admit electronic evidence reported that it is treated in
the same way as physical evidence. Just under 40 per cent of countries, for example, reported the
existence of a legal distinction between electronic and physical evidence.43 While approaches vary,
many countries considered that it was good practice not to make a distinction, as this ensures fair
admissibility of electronic evidence alongside all other types of evidence. For countries without a
legal distinction between electronic and physical evidence, many reported that electronic evidence,
like its traditional counterpart, ‘must be: admissible; authentic; accurate; complete and convincing to juries.’44
Admissibility of electronic evidence was also reported to be dependent on the general rules that
apply to all evidence, including that the elements ‘were obtained legally, respecting the principles of relevance
and abundance.’45 In a few countries, courts have the discretion to ‘to decide whether any [electronic] evidence
is admissible or not.’46
Electronic evidence was reported to be transferred to prosecution or judicial authorities,
and used in a criminal trial, in a number of ways. Responding countries reported all of: the physical
transportation of seized computers to court; the use in court of copies of computer data stored on
optical disk; the use in court of printouts of electronic evidence filed in binders; and the presentation
of an expert analytical report and testimony only to the court (with the computer data remaining in
storage).47 A few countries stated, for instance, that electronic documents or data ‘must be printed out
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q145.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q143.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q143.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q144.
Ibid.
Ibid.
166
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents