relationship to evidence presentation in court based on successful previous presentations’69 were important
components of successful prosecutions and convictions. Finally, a ‘perceived lack of fluency in the legal
community with respect to technological concepts and how these impact the administration of justice’70 and
‘understanding of digital evidence by judicial officers’71 were reported as additional obstacles to successful
prosecution and conviction in cybercrime cases.
Additional training and resources were indicated as challenges, including ‘better guidance to the
courts at all levels by summarizing (and sharing) judicial experience to allow identification and uniform standards in
computer information system security cases.’72 One country highlighted that ‘It is important and decisive for good
management of cybercrime cases, that the national courts have adequate financial means to acquire necessary technical
equipment.’73 The necessity for public-private partnerships with ‘internet access providers, website hosting
providers, and other service providers’74 and banking and telecommunications companies was also reported
as a productive method to enhance evidence collection.
Criminal justice system effectiveness and outcomes
Core aims of the criminal justice response, to any crime, are to achieve just outcomes for
perpetrators and victims, alongside specific deterrence, rehabilitation and societal reintegration for
convicted offenders, and a sense of general deterrence for potential perpetrators.75 Measurement of
how ‘efficiently’ or ‘effectively’ this is achieved is extremely challenging. Measures range from
‘attrition’ rates that provide information on the numbers of persons suspected, prosecuted, and
convicted by the criminal justice system for specific crimes, to measures of ‘timeliness’ of case
disposition, ‘punitivity’ and ‘recidivism.’76 While such measures are commonly reported, it should be
noted that they do not represent direct indicators of the ‘quality’ of justice, and can be heavily
influenced by differences in criminal justice system mechanisms, such as the application of suspect
counting rules, thresholds applied in recording of cases, or prosecutorial involvement in the initial
investigation stage.
Nonetheless, with a view to further understanding the criminal justice system response to
cybercrime, the Study questionnaire asked countries to report available statistics on the number of
recorded cybercrime offences, and numbers of persons suspected (or ‘brought into formal contact
with the police’) for cybercrime offences, as well as numbers of persons prosecuted and convicted
for cybercrime offences.77
As noted in Chapter Two (The global picture), reported police statistics were found not to
represent a strong basis for cross-national comparative measurement of cybercrime trends.78 Law
enforcement and criminal justice statistics within individual countries may, however, allow case and
suspect ‘attrition’ calculations for that country, where reported case numbers are not small, and yearto-year effects (such as cases carried over from one year to the next) can be accounted for.
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q141.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q142.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q183.
Ibid.
Albanese, J.S., 2012. Criminal Justice. 5th edn. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall.
See for example, Harrendorf, S., Smit, P., 2010. Attributes of criminal justice systems – resources, performance and punitivity. In:
European Institute for Crime Prevention and Control Affiliated with the United Nations (HEUNI). 2010. International Statistics on
Crime and Justice. Helsinki.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q54-70, Q121-137, and Q165-181.
See Chapter Two (The global picture), Section 2.1 Measuring cybercrime, and Section 2.3 Cybercrime perpetrators, ‘Typical
offender’ profiles.
170
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents