CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
In general, responding countries were able to provide comparatively few law enforcement,
criminal justice, and court statistics. For a set of six countries, mostly in Europe, however, it was
possible to calculate the average number of persons brought into formal contact with law
enforcement
Figure 6.6: Persons brought into formal contact per recorded offence (6 countries)
authorities
per
recorded offence for
Recorded offences = 100
the cybercrime acts
of illegal access,
Illegal access (suspects)
computer-related
fraud and forgery,
Computer‐related fraud/forgery
(suspects)
and
child
pornography
(Rape (suspects))
offences.
Child pornography (suspects)
Figure 6.6
shows these results
(Homicide (suspects))
alongside
the
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
suspects to offence
Suspects relative to recorded offences
ratios for rape and
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q54‐70.
homicide in the
same six countries.79 A significant difference exists between child pornography offences and the
other computer offences of illegal access and fraud or forgery. Suspect to offence ratios for child
pornography are similar to that for ‘conventional’ crimes. Those for illegal access and computerrelated fraud or forgery are significantly lower – representing around 25 recorded suspects per 100
offences.
This may be indicative of a number of factors, including differences in police investigative
capabilities for different cybercrime offences, differences in police investigative focus, and variations
in the point at which different cybercrime acts are recorded as offences for statistical purposes. In
addition, however, the
Figure 6.7: Criminal justice system attrition in cybercrime cases
pattern
may
reveal
(Rape)
genuine
underlying
differences in the steps
(Homicide)
taken by, and capabilities
of, perpetrators to conceal
Child pornography offences
criminal activity and to
Computer‐related copyright or
evade detection by law
trademark offences
enforcement
Computer‐related fraud or
Number of recorded offences
investigations.
forgery
Persons brought into formal contact
Illegal acess to computer data
Persons prosecuted
While suspect to
Persons convicted
offence ratios could be
0
100
200
300
400
calculated as an average
Number of offences/persons
for a number of countries,
Source: Cybercrime study questionnaire. Q54‐70.
sufficient statistics for
calculation of a complete ‘offence to conviction’ attrition rate were provided by only one country in
response to the Study questionnaire. Figure 6.7 shows the number of police recorded offences,
79
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q54-70; and United Nations Survey of Crime Trends and Operations of Criminal Justice Systems,
latest available year.
171
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents