where the offence occurred.’54 One component of this provision includes: ‘[an offence is committed]… (iii) at
any location which the resulting action is an element of an offence pursuant to… this Law occurred or would have
occurred.’55 The EU Directive on Child Exploitation requires jurisdiction where the offence is
committed in whole ‘or in part’ within the territory. It clarifies that this includes where the offence is
committed by means of information and communication technology ‘accessed from’ the territory
‘whether or not’ the technology is based in the territory.56 The EU Decision on Attacks against
Information Systems covers both attacks committed by an offender physically present on the
territory (whether or not against an information system on the territory), and attacks against
information systems on the territory (whether or not the offender is physically present on the
territory).57
National approaches – The influence of
territoriality approaches in international and regional
instruments is seen at national level. Countries
reported a range of provisions reflecting the idea that
the ‘whole’ offence need not take place within the
country in order to assert territorial jurisdiction.
Mechanisms varied, however, for identifying the
existence of a territorial connection.
Example of cyber-specific legislation
covering territorial jurisdiction in cybercrime
cases from a country in Southern Africa
Jurisdiction of courts.
A court in the Republic trying an offence in
terms of this Act has jurisdiction where—
(a) the offence was committed in the Republic;
(b) any act of preparation towards the offence or
any part of the offence was committed in the
Republic, or where any result of the offence
has had an effect in the Republic;
(c) …
(d) the offence was committed on board any ship
or aircraft registered in the Republic or on a
voyage or flight to or from the Republic at
the time that the offence was committed.
In some cases, these focused on the ‘act.’ In
other cases, they focused on the location of ‘computer
systems and data.’58 Some countries reported, for
example, that territorial jurisdiction included crimes
that are initiated, continued or completed elsewhere,
but are either partly ‘carried out,’ or ‘affect’ property, or
‘cause’ personal harm, within the state territory.59 Other
countries referred to the assertion of jurisdiction
where ‘server or hardware utilized for the commission of the crime’ is located outside of the territory, but
where there is ‘some kind of domestic effect or element.’ 60
Examination of case law also shows that national courts have claimed jurisdiction where all
of the elements of a crime are within the country, except for the result (in this case, harm to an extraterritorial victim receiving harassing messages).61 Conversely, law enforcement authorities have also
issued indictments where the crime result (of illegal access and fraudulent loss) was within the
country, but the conduct and location of the perpetrators was extra-territorial.62 Countries observed
that such concepts had been applied to cases involving internet gambling and child pornography.63
A small number of countries from Europe and the Americas reported, however, that national
legislation was insufficient to address some specific extra-territorial cybercrime acts – including denial
of service, sending of spam, and phishing attacks.64
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 40(f).
Ibid. Art 40(f)(iii).
EU Directive on Child Exploitation, Art. 17.
EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 10.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q18.
Ibid.
Ibid.
DPP v. Sutcliffe [2001] VSC 43. 1 March 2001.
US v Tsastsin et al. United States District Court. Southern District of New York. S2 11 Cr. 878.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q18.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q19.
192
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents