CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION Many countries stated that they would not have jurisdiction over an act carried out, and taking effect, entirely outside of the territory. One country in Asia, however, reported that it could assert jurisdiction in such circumstances if computer systems or other equipment used in the offence were located on its territory.65 While a conceptual distinction exists between ‘offence elements and effects,’ and ‘computer systems used in the offence’, it is likely that there is significant overlap between these two approaches – in particular where the use of computer systems can be characterized as part of the ‘conduct’ or ‘circumstance’ offence elements. Finally, some countries noted the constraints of nationality on territoriality. Even where territorial jurisdiction could be asserted – such as when an extra-territorial act is covered by the effects doctrine – many countries reported that the situation was unclear if the extra-territorial perpetrator Example of legislation that specifically was a foreign national. Several countries noted that they extends territorial jurisdiction to nononly initiated proceedings when additional nationals from a country in the Caribbean 66 requirements are met. In one country, for example, (1) Subject to subsection (2), this Act shall have criminalization and prosecution of such foreign effect in relation to any person, whatever his nationality or citizenship, outside as well as suspects depends on whether the offence significantly within the State, and where an offence under this harms its interests and internal security.67 A small Act is committed by a person in any place number of countries in Asia and the Americas outside of the State, he may be dealt with as if the offence had been committed within the State. reported allowing for jurisdiction over offenders of (2) For the purpose of subsection (1), this Act any nationality, regardless of the place where the shall apply if, for the offence in question— (a) the accused was in the State at the material offence itself is committed – as long as some link time; could be established, such as the presence of the (b) the computer, program or data was in the perpetrator, or the device or data utilized in the State at the material time; or (c) the damage occurred within the State, offence, within the territory at the material time, or the whether or not paragraph (a) or (b) applies. occurrence of damage within the territory.68 For the situation where an alleged foreign perpetrator remains physically present in the territory, some countries referred to the obligation to ‘extradite or prosecute.’ Using nationality-based jurisdiction International and regional instruments – Where international or regional cybercrime instruments recognize the territoriality principle, they frequently also include the active nationality principle – requiring a state to ensure jurisdiction when the act has been committed by one of its nationals, including outside of the national territory.69 Some instruments require that the national’s conduct is also criminalized in the country where it occurred.70 Only a limited number of instruments provide for jurisdiction based on the passive nationality principle – notably those that concern the rights of children. The EU Directive on Child Exploitation, and the United Nations OP-CRC-SC require states to establish jurisdiction over an offence committed outside of the territory against ‘one of its nationals,’ or a person who is a ‘habitual 65 66 67 68 69 70 Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q18. Ibid. Ibid. For instance, see Computer Crimes Act of Malaysia (1997), Art. 9; Computer Misuse Act of Singapore (Revised, 2007), Art. 11; Computer Misuse Act of Trinidad and Tobago (2000), Art. 12. See, for example, Council of Europe Child Protection Convention, Art. 25(1)(d), and EU Directive on Child Exploitation, Art. 17(1)(b). See COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art.40(c); Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 4(d); Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 22(1)(d); and League of Arab States Model Law 2004, Art. 30(1)(d). 193

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents