Sufficient jurisdiction?
Overall, analysis of provisions in international and regional instruments, and the law and
practice of states, suggests that cybercrime jurisdictional challenges can be resolved by ensuring
clarity, and innovative application, of existing principles.
As highlighted by commentators, ‘transactions in cyberspace involve real people in one territorial
jurisdiction either (i) transacting with real people in other territorial jurisdictions or (ii) engaging in activity in one
jurisdiction that causes real-world effects in another territorial jurisdiction.’91 As a result, forms of territoriality
and nationality-based jurisdiction are almost always able to ensure that a ‘sufficient connection’ or
‘genuine link’ can be established between cybercrime acts and at least one state. This Study does not
therefore find that there is a need, at present, for additional jurisdiction over a ‘cyberspace’
dimension. The vast majority of cybercrime acts fall within the two categories above and can be
genuinely linked to particular states. As such – and as discussed later in this Chapter – the fact that
data are increasingly transient and dispersed through global data centres, currently presents a
challenge more for the collection of evidence, than it is does for establishment of jurisdiction. To the
extent that the elements and effects of an individual cybercrime act could all be transient and dispersed,
forms of jurisdiction may still rely on nationality-based principles and (for legal persons), place of
incorporation principles.
As discussed in Chapter Four (Criminalization) in the context of international human rights
law, however, one risk of the projection of extensive extra-territorial jurisdiction may be to the
plurality of internet content. At the heart of the jurisdictional debate, lies interpretation of the
placement of offence elements and effects within geographical boundaries. Whether this is viewed
from the perspective of ‘acts,’ ‘conduct,’ ‘circumstances,’ ‘data,’ or ‘computer systems,’ the avoidance
of jurisdictional conflicts must depend upon the maintenance of a sufficiently high threshold for the
‘genuine link’ – together with clear inter-state communication channels for coordination of extraterritorial criminal justice actions.
91
Post, D.G., 2002. Against ‘Against Cyberanarchy.’ Berkeley Technology Law Journal (17):1365-1387.
196
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents