The use of ‘traditional’ modes of cooperation may not present difficulties when used between countries that are also parties to multilateral instruments. Countries will likely be able to request specialized cybercrime investigative measures – such as preservation of computer data – as both parties will have the relevant procedural powers in national law. Use of ‘traditional’ modes where at least one country is not also party to a multilateral instrument, however, may present challenges. This is the case for the majority of countries in the world. Globally, over 60 per cent of countries are not party to any multilateral cybercrime instrument – with the result that they have no international legal obligation to either include specialized cybercrime investigative powers in national procedural laws, or to carry out specialized investigations in response to cooperation requests.116 Some 20 per cent of responding countries reported, for example, that national legislation does not provide for expedited preservation of computer data.117 As might be expected, the majority (80 per cent) of these countries have not signed or ratified any of the binding international or regional cybercrime instruments. Presently, requests for international cooperation to such countries must be made by ‘traditional’ bilateral and reciprocity-based means. However, if actions such as expedited preservation of data are requested, the request may suffer from: (i) a lack of clarity concerning whether such measures can be requested under the relevant bilateral instrument or arrangement, and/or (ii) the non-existence of such measures under national criminal procedure law. Dual criminality and other conditions in cybercrime cooperation Use of international cooperation for the investigation of cybercrime acts can also create challenges regarding the equivalence of criminalization. Cooperation requests are commonly subject to a range of both procedural and substantive requirements – in respect of which the requested state must be satisfied before consent can be granted. One key requirement is that of dual criminality. The principle of dual criminality requires that the act to which a request relates be a crime according to the criminal law of the requested state, as well as the requesting state.118 Dual criminality features in international and regional cybercrime instruments. It is required for extradition, and envisaged for forms of mutual legal assistance, for example, under the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention and the League of Arab States Convention.119 A key factor in establishing dual criminality is the substantive underlying conduct, and not the technical terms or definitions of the crime in national laws.120 The Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention clarifies that dual criminality shall be deemed fulfilled ‘irrespective of whether its laws place the offence within the same category of offence or denominate the offence by the same terminology as the requesting Party’ if ‘the conduct underlying the offence’ for which assistance is sought ‘is a criminal offence under its laws.’121 According to this approach, the focus is on ‘transposing’ the elements of the act into the law of the requested state in order to confirm that the act would also be a criminal offence.122 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 Although, as noted in Chapter Five (Law enforcement and investigations), they may well make use of existing general investigative powers. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q49. UNODC, 2012. Manual on Mutual Legal Assistance and Extradition. Dual or double criminality is not so much a rule of customary international law as a treaty and statute consideration based on policy and expediency (Williams, S.A., 1991. The Double Criminality Rule and Extradition: A Comparative Analysis. Nova Law review, 15:582). References to the concept can be found in Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Arts. 24(1), 25(5), 29(3) and (4); League of Arab States Convention, Arts. 32(5), 37(3) and (4). Article 43(2) of the United Nations Convention against Corruption, for example, states that ‘In matters of international cooperation, whenever dual criminality is considered a requirement, it shall be deemed fulfilled irrespective of whether the laws of the requested State Party place the offence within the same category of offence or denominate the offence by the same terminology as the requesting State Party, if the conduct underlying the offence for which assistance is sought is a criminal offence under the laws of both States Parties.’ Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 25(5). Two approaches exist in this respect: Dual criminality in abstracto and dual criminality in concreto. ‘In abstracto’ means that consideration of the behaviour in question is limited to the question of whether the behaviour is punishable, regardless of its legal qualification or the existence of possible reasons excluding punishability. ‘In concreto’ means that the behaviour fulfils all 202

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents