CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
both extradition and mutual legal assistance.135 In the case of extradition, countries also frequently
identified expected procedural requirements such as a copy of the arrest warrant or judgement, and
evidence that the suspect was in the jurisdiction.136 In the case of mutual legal assistance, countries
identified conditions such as assurances regarding the sufficiency of evidence requested, and an
authenticated statement of facts.137
While a number of countries indicated that they had not rejected any cybercrime extradition
or assistance request to date, a failure to satisfy both procedural and substantive requirements was
emphasized by countries when asked about common reasons for rejection of requests.138 Countries
most commonly reported procedural irregularities and insufficient provision of evidence –
highlighting the need for the careful preparation of cooperation requests.139 Substantive reasons
provided concerned dual criminality, and international human rights law obligations.140 Notably, one
country reported the practical problem of ‘volatility of computer data’ as a reason for refusing mutual
legal assistance requests141 – perhaps indicating that requests could not be fulfilled as relevant
electronic evidence had already been deleted. This relates closely to the time needed for response to
formal modes of cooperation – an issue addressed below.
Extradition and mutual legal assistance in practice
Available statistics reported through the Study questionnaire show that extradition and
mutual legal assistance are used to varying extents by countries. Around half of responding countries
reported fewer than 10 cybercrime extradition or mutual legal assistance cases sent or received per
year.142 The average number of cases was 8 per year, with three-quarters of all reported cases falling
within the range of 3 to 45 cases per year. Countries with the highest numbers of cases were
typically larger countries in Europe or North America.
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
Figure 7.7: Average response time (days) for cybercrime
extradition and MLA requests
250
Average time for response (days)
The distribution of cybercrime
offences that are the subject of extradition
and mutual legal assistance requests is largely
similar to the total caseload handled by law
enforcement in general – constituting
around one-third each of acts against the
confidentiality, integrity and availability of
computer systems or data, acts for personal
or financial gain or harm, and contentrelated acts.143 Measures most commonly
reported to be available to requesting states
for the investigation of these acts include
provision of stored content or traffic data,
or search and seizure of computer hardware
or data.144 In line with the fact that some
200
150
100
50
0
Extradition
(n=9, r=13)
MLA
(n=16, r=27)
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q213 and Q238.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q198 and Q220.
Ibid. (Q198).
Ibid. (Q220).
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q214 and Q239.
Ibid.
Ibid. (Q239).
Ibid. (Q239).
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q202-206 and Q227-231.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q208-211 and Q233-236.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q221.
205
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents