countries do not have specialized investigative powers, such as preservation of computer data or
real-time collection of content or traffic data in national laws, only around 35 per cent and 45 per
cent of countries, respectively, reported that such actions could be requested through mutual legal
assistance.145
While the range of offences covered and investigative powers available through formal
international cooperation is expansive, the mechanism is challenged by long response times in
practice. Countries reported median response times of 120 days for extradition requests, and 150
days for mutual legal assistance requests, received and sent.146 The data should be considered with
some caution, due to the comparatively low number of countries that responded to the question,
and due to the possibility that countries applied a range of timescale definitions in responding to the
question – for example, from ‘request receipt’ to ‘initial response’, or from ‘request receipt’ to
‘substantive resolution’. Given the fact that 75 per cent of all responses times reported fall within
the ‘error bar’ lines,147 however, it is clear that the use of formal cooperation mechanisms occurs on
a timescale of months, rather than days.
Long time scales in international cooperation may be related to reliance on ‘traditional’
formal channels of communication that typically necessitate the involvement of multiple authorities
in the communication chain. All countries, for example, reported using post or diplomatic letters for
both extradition and mutual assistance requests in cybercrime cases.148 A number of countries
highlighted that the manner of
Figure 7.8: Forms of communication in cybercrime cases
transmission of requests is governed by
the provisions of the relevant bilateral
100%
treaty or multilateral convention. In
Post/Diplomatic letters
100%
some cases, these include the
50%
requirement for formal modes of
Email
31%
communication.149
Fax
50%
24%
MLA
Mechanisms
of
formal
Extradition
5%
cooperation usually require the
Online web‐based system
2%
designation of ‘central authorities’ –
9%
and it is these authorities that typically
Other/Telephone
handle incoming and outgoing requests
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q197 and Q219. (n=44,47, r=77,94)
by post or diplomatic letters. The
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, for example, requires States parties to establish ‘a
list of competent authorities.’150 The Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention requires parties to
indicate central authorities for extradition and for mutual legal assistance.151 Insofar as cybercrime
cases are largely handled in the same way as other crime cases, countries reported typical institutions
assigned to the role of central authority also for cybercrime cooperation matters.152 These included
Offices of the Attorney General or Prosecutor General, and Ministries of Justice.153 Some countries
noted that different authorities were assigned the role of central authority depending upon the stage
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q213 and Q238.
Error bars on the figure represent upper and lower quartiles.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q197 and Q219.
Ibid.
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art 4.
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Arts. 24 and 27. Competent authorities notified under these articles are listed at:
http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/cooperation/economiccrime/cybercrime/Documents/Internationalcooperation/Res_internatcoop_au
thorities_en.asp
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q195 and Q217.
Ibid.
206
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents