CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION of proceedings.154 While the central authority is responsible for coordinating a request, the ultimate decision on a request often lies with a different national authority.155 For countries in Europe, for example, authorization of requests is not handled uniformly – ranging from a decision by a lower domestic court, to a decision by the executive branch of government.156 In the other regions, prosecutors or magistrates also play an important role. The (often necessary) interplay between a range of government institutions can, in some cases, contribute to the long timescales reported for responses to requests. As highlighted in Chapter Five (Electronic evidence and criminal justice), electronic evidence is volatile and may exist only for short periods of time – in many cases, significantly shorter time periods than those reported by states above. A number of responding countries highlighted, for example, that: ‘Formal international cooperation mechanisms such as Mutual Legal Assistance (MLA) can be time consuming and cause delay in the investigation and prosecution of cybercrime offenses.’157 National laws governing mutual legal assistance very rarely contain cyber-specific provisions that reflect this reality.158 Nonetheless, some bilateral and multilateral instruments, as well as national laws, do sometimes allow for expedited forms of communication, such as email, fax, or online systems.159 The Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention and League of Arab States Convention, for example, provide that ‘in urgent circumstances’ parties may make requests for mutual assistance by expedited means of communication, including fax or email, with formal confirmation to follow.160 Non-binding instruments also envisage use of ‘the most efficient means, […] provided that appropriate levels of authentication and security are utilized and formal confirmation follows the request or response.’161 During information gathering for the Study, around half of responding countries reported the use of email or fax for mutual legal assistance requests. A much smaller proportion – 5 per cent – reported use of an online system. As might be expected given the role of mutual legal assistance in the investigation phase, the use of expedited forms of communication was greater for mutual legal assistance requests than for extradition requests.162 In line with the requirements of international and regional cybercrime instruments, many countries noted that such communications were also followed-up by the use of post and diplomatic letters.163 One country from South America stated that it used email and fax in order to monitor the extradition process, while Western Asian respondents pointed out that they only resorted to electronic communication in urgent cases.164 Roughly in line with levels of reported use of email, fax and telephone, over 60 per cent of countries in Africa, the Americas and Europe reported the existence of channels for urgent mutual legal assistance requests. Only 20 per cent of countries in Asia and Oceania, however, reported the existence of such channels. More than one third of respondents referred to specific urgent channel mechanisms, including INTERPOL national central bureaus, and G8 and Council of Europe 24/7 networks.165 Being party to an international or regional instrument envisaging urgent mutual legal assistance channels appears to have a moderate effect – 55 per cent of responding countries that 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 Ibid. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q218. Ibid. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q141. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q193 and Q216. Ibid. Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 25(3), and League of Arab States Convention, Art. 32(3). COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 43(b). Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q197 and Q219. Ibid. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q222. Ibid. 207

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents