information gathering for the Study, for example, one country noted that the national contact point
for the G8 network is located within a law enforcement institution, while the national contact point
for the 24/7 network established under the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention is located
within a prosecution office attached to a superior court.173 The presence of multiple contact points
in a country can make it challenging for other countries to know which focal point to approach. It
may also lead to delay in responding to requests when requested countries need to verify the validity
or identity of a focal point from a mechanism with which they have not previously communicated.
National approaches to informal cooperation
The majority of responding
countries indicated that assistance can
be provided informally, as well as
through
formal
mutual
legal
assistance.174 The proportion of
countries able to provide informal
assistance was notably higher in
Europe, Asia and Oceania and the
Americas (between 70 and 90 per
cent) than in Africa (around 50 per
cent).175
Figure 7.11: Can assistance be provided informally, as well as
through a formal MLA request?
Europe
(n=14)
Yes
No
Asia &
Oceania
(n=17)
Americas
(n=8)
Africa
(n=6)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q223. (n=45)
Countries that make use of
informal cooperation noted that such mechanisms were dependent upon the existence of a
competent and well-organized foreign counterpart. Countries observed that this was more likely
when informal law enforcement cooperation was governed by some form of agreement. A number
of countries reported that informal cooperation is therefore conducted on the basis of regional and
bilateral agreements, through use of networks established by international and regional organizations
and institutions; with the assistance of embassies and consulates; as well as through private networks
among law enforcement officers.176 While some countries referred to direct police-to-police
cooperation, others spoke primarily of informal cooperation through INTERPOL channels.177 One
country noted that this was consistent with the realities of international legal cooperation, insofar as
informal means of communication – however flexible and useful they might be – often only exist
among states who have developed long-term working relationships.178 Exchange of international
case information through established international police channels is identified as a necessary step to
the successful investigations.
Even though informal modes of cooperation are likely more effective when based on a clear
agreement, the majority of countries reported that the use of informal cooperation, rather than
formal mutual legal assistance, was not subject to a defined policy.179 A number of countries,
however, did highlight the existence of guidelines and protocols, including ‘unwritten’ rules.
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
Response from regional expert nominated by WEOG to preliminary results from the Study.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q223.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q106 and Q223.
Response from regional expert nominated by Asian Group to preliminary results from the Study.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q224.
210
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents