CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
Differing global perspectives on the acceptability of forms of internet content leave a
number of theoretical alternatives. States could choose to restrict the scope of their criminal
jurisdiction to activities of perpetrators on their own national territory. They could focus on the
prosecution of persons within their territory accessing content, irrespective of its source. Or they
could attempt extraterritorial action against content producers. Such perspectives illustrate the
growing extent of legal differences and approaches in the area of cybercrime. Chapter Four
(Criminalization) examines this point in greater depth, including from the perspective of
international human rights law.
Some divergences between
national laws can be traced back to
fundamental differences between
legal families. Major legal families
commonly
identified
include
continental
European
law,18
common law,19 Islamic law,20 and
mixed law (such as Chinese law).21
Country responses to the Study
questionnaire show that a broad
range of legal systems are
represented.22
Figure 3.2: Classification of national legal system of responding
countries
24%
Civil law
2%
28%
Mixed system
Common law
Islamic law
46%
Legal families are an
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q15. (n=54)
important way of characterizing legal
heritage, including where systems share particular features, due for instance to common cultural
roots.23 Nonetheless, national laws are not static, and similarities between systems may exist at a
certain point in time, but subsequently vanish.24 As such, historic differences can disappear or lose
their practical relevance.
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Continental European criminal law is often characterized by abstract normative rules, systematic structures and a strong influence
of academic thinking. Criminal law is usually extensively codified with penal codes also providing for general principles of criminal
responsibility applicable to all forms of criminal behaviour. See Zweigert, K., Kötz, H. 1998. Comparative Law. 3rd ed. Oxford/New
York: Clarendon Press, p.69. See also Weigend, T. 2011. In: Heller, K.J., Dubber, M.D. (eds.) The Handbook of Comparative Criminal
Law, Stanford: Stanford University Press, pp.256 et seq.; Elliott, C., ibid., p.213.; Gómez-Jara Díez, C., Chiesa, L.E., ibid., p.493;
Thaman, S.C., ibid., p.416.
In contrast, in common law jurisdictions, substantive laws provisions are more usually drafted in descriptive terms, ensuring both
accessibility of law, and reflecting the strong position of lay judges within common law jurisdictions. Judge-made law was long the
main source of the substantive criminal law and still remains an important element. Codification, however, is now a widespread
norm, albeit sometimes through separate legislative acts rather than one single penal code. See Legeais, R., 2004. Grands systèmes de
droit contemporains. Paris: Litec, pp.357, 366; Ashworth, A. (United Kingdom). 2011, p.533, and also Robinson, P. (United States)
2011, p.564. Both in: Heller, K.J., Dubber, M.D. (eds.) The Handbook of Comparative Criminal Law, Stanford: Stanford University
Press; Simester, A.P., Spencer, J.R., Sullivan, G.R., Virgo, G.J. 2010. Criminal Law. 4th ed. Oxford/Portland: Hart Publishing, p.46;
Ashworth, A. 2009. Principles of Criminal Law. 6th ed. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press, p.8.
Islamic law is characterized by Shari’a, the sacred law of Islam, and fiqh, the jurisprudence of Islamic jurists. Crimes are categorized
according to their legal sources and to punishments provided. A number of core offences are sanctioned by the use of fixed
penalties (hudud). Other core offences are punished through legal reasoning based on Ijma and Qiyas. In general, Islamic laws
allow for extensive flexibility as regards criminalization, including through the evolution of different theological schools of law. See
Tellenbach, S., 2011. In: Heller, K.J., Dubber, M.D. (eds.) The Handbook of Comparative Criminal Law. Stanford: Stanford University
Press, p.321.
Chinese criminal law has been influenced by a range of legal systems with the judiciary retaining important powers to give binding
judicial interpretations of law. See Luo, W., 2011. In: Heller, K.J., Dubber, M.D. (eds.) The Handbook of Comparative Criminal Law.
Stanford: Stanford University Press, p.138; and Bu, Y., 2009. Einführung in das Recht Chinas. Munich: C.H. Beck, p. 20.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q15.
See Ferrante, M., 2011. In: Heller, K.J., Dubber, M.D. (eds.) The Handbook of Comparative Criminal Law. Stanford: Stanford University
Press, p.13.
Zweigert, K., Kötz, H. 1998. Comparative Law. 3rd ed. Oxford/New York: Clarendon Press, p.66.
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents