CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
and can include intentional unauthorized entry to computer systems – such as those used for critical
national infrastructure. Reference to the ‘maximum’ possible penal sentence for the purposes of
determining cooperation thresholds does not necessarily well characterize the act itself. Alternative
approaches, such as defining a list of specific crimes to which international cooperation provisions
apply (without a need for penal thresholds), suffer from the limitations of restricted scope. Overall,
broad harmonization of penalties between countries for specific core cybercrime offences –
including common seriousness-based penalty levels – likely could assist in facilitating international
cooperation and the elimination of ‘penalty havens�� for perpetrators.
Summary
The current picture of cybercrime legislation is a dynamic one – indicating ongoing legal
reform and increasing recognition that cybercrime requires a legal response across multiple areas:
criminal, civil and administrative. Almost 60 per cent of responding countries indicated new or
planned cybercrime legislation in their response to the Study questionnaire.56 While ‘traditional’
general law can be applied to cybercrime matters to some extent, the intangible nature of concepts
such as ‘computer data’ also requires the introduction of specific offences, definitions, and concepts
– if legal interests such as the integrity of computer systems are to be protected.
While consensus exists about broad areas of legal intervention for the prevention and
combating of cybercrime, levels of harmonization of legislation as between countries viewed as
important for cooperation, within regions, and with multilateral instruments, are perceived to be
highly variable. This includes in the area of cybercrime offence penalties, where an examination of
one foundational crime – illegal access – shows divergence to the extent that smooth international
cooperation concerning this crime may be affected. Harmonization itself is required for reasons,
amongst others, of the elimination of criminal safe havens, and for global evidence collection.
Routes to harmonization include the use of binding and non-binding international and regional
instruments. As alluded to in the Study thus far, many such instruments exist. The next section of
this Chapter examines these in detail.
3.3 Overview of international and regional instruments
Key results:
56
The last decade has seen significant developments in the promulgation of international
and regional instruments aimed at countering cybercrime. These include binding and nonbinding instruments
Five clusters of international or regional instruments can be identified, consisting of
instruments developed in the context of, or inspired by: (i) the Council of Europe or the
European Union, (ii) the Commonwealth of Independent States or the Shanghai
Cooperation Organization, (iii) intergovernmental African organizations, (iv) the League
of Arab States, and (v) the United Nations
A significant amount of cross-fertilization exists between all instruments, including, in
particular, concepts and approaches developed in the Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention
Analysis of provisions of 19 multilateral instruments relevant to cybercrime shows
common core provisions, but also significant divergence in substantive areas addressed
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q14.
63
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents