A/76/136
2.
The application of international law in cyberspace
Key message:
International law applies in cyberspace.
Existing international law, that is customary international law and international
treaties, has not been developed with cyberspace in mind. However, the application
of the rules of international law to new areas, for example in response to technological
developments, is nothing new. If the law in certain areas is perceived as unclear when
applied to activities in cyberspace, this must be resolved in the usual way through
interpretation. This applies both to general international law, for instance the rules
that relate to sovereignty and state responsibility, and to the specialised regimes of
international law, such as international human rights law and international
humanitarian law.
Norway is of the view that there is no need for specific legal instruments to set
out rights and obligations of States in respect of activities in cyberspace.
3.
Cyber operations in violation of international law
Key message:
One of the conditions for holding a State internationally responsible for a cyber
operation is that the operation, or the failure to react against the operation,
constitutes a breach of an international obligation of the State.
Cyber operations can vary widely in scope and intensity, from minor digital
disruptions to armed attacks on a State. One of the conditions for holding a State
internationally responsible for a cyber operation is that the operation, or the failure to
react against the operation, constitutes a breach of an international obligation of the
State. 175 The obligation in question may follow from customary international law or
be treaty-based. A cyber operation is thus not unlawful per se but may become so
when carried out to the detriment of the rights of other States.
In the following, Norway gives its interpretation of certain obligations of
international law as they apply to cyber operations. 176 The focus in Section 3 is on
sovereignty, non-intervention and the prohibition on the use of force. The question of
attribution of conduct to a State, which is the other condition for holding a State
internationally responsible for a cyber operation, is dealt with in Section 4 (State
responsibility). The measures a targeted State is entitled to use in response under
international law are dealt with in Section 5 (Response measures). Section 6 discusses
international humanitarian law as it applies to cyber operations in armed conflict, and
Section 7 deals with the application of international human rights obligations in
cyberspace.
__________________
175
176
66/142
This is set out as one of two conditions in Article 2 of the International Law Commission’s Articles on
State Responsibility (ILC ASR). The Article is considered to express customary international law.
This position paper does not contain any specific analysis of cyber espionage, that is cyber operations
whose purpose and effect is limited to the mere collection of information for use by the authorities,
which is not in itself illegal under international law. However, certain aspects of such intelligence
operations could violate specific rules of international law.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents