A/76/136
3.1
Sovereignty
Key message:
Sovereignty is not just a principle, but also a primary rule of international law.
A State must not conduct cyber operations that violate another State’s
sovereignty.
Whether a cyber operation violates the target State’s sovereignty depends on
the nature of the operation, the scale of the intrusion and its consequences, and
must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.
The principle of sovereignty is one of the fundamental principles of
international law and applies in cyberspace. 177 It refers to the supreme authority of
every State within its territory to the exclusion of other States, and also in its relations
with other States.
The internal dimension of a State’s sovereignty includes the exclusive right to
exercise jurisdiction within its territory, including over the information systems
located on its territory, and to exercise independent State powers. The external
dimension includes the right of the State to decide its foreign policy and to enter into
international agreements. Both dimensions of sovereignty apply in cyberspace,
subject only to obligations under international law.
Norway is of the view that sovereignty constitutes both an international law
principle from which various rules derive, such as the prohibition of intervention and
the prohibition of the use of force, and a primary rule in its own right capable of being
violated. 178 Thus, cyber operations that do not amount to a prohibited intervention or
a prohibited use of force may nevertheless amount to a violation of a State’s
sovereignty under international law.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has consistently held that States have
an obligation to respect the territorial integrity and political independence of other
States as a matter of international law. In a cyber context this means that a State must
not conduct cyber operations that violate another State’s sovereignty.
A cyber operation that manifests itself on another State’s territory may,
depending on its nature, the scale of the intrusion and its consequences,
constitute a violation of sovereignty.
Causing physical damage by cyber means on another State’s territory may easily
qualify as a violation of territorial sovereignty. For example, a cyber operation against
an industrial control system at a petrochemical plant that led to a malfunction and a
subsequent fire would constitute a violation of the State’s territorial sovereignty. In
addition to physical damage, causing cyber infrastructure to lose functionality may
also be taken into consideration and may amount to a violation. This includes the use
of crypto viruses to encrypt data and thus render them unusable for a substantial
period of time.
__________________
177
178
21-09670
Island of Palmas case (USA v Netherlands), arbitral award, 4 April 1928: ‘Sovereignty in the relations
between States signifies independence. Independence in regard to a portion of the globe is the right to
exercise therein, to the exclusion of any other State, the functions of a State’, p. 838.
Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v. United States of
America), ‘Nicaragua case’, International Court of Justice (ICJ), judgment 27 June 1986, paras. 15,
212–213 and 292.
67/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents