A/76/136
A cyber operation may constitute use of force or even an armed attack if its scale
and effects are comparable to those of the use of force or an armed attack by
conventional means. This must be determined based on a case-by-case assessment
having regard to the specific circumstances. A number of factors may be taken into
consideration, such as the severity of the consequences (the level of harm inflicted),
immediacy, directness, invasiveness, measurability, military character, State
involvement, the nature of the target (such as critical infrastructure) and whether this
category of action has generally been characterised as the use of force. 190 This list is
not exhaustive.
Cyber operations that cause death or injury to persons or physical damage to or
the destruction of objects could clearly amount to the use of force. Likewise, a cyber
operation causing severe disruption to the functioning of the State such as the use of
crypto viruses or other forms of digital sabotage against governmental or private
power grid- or telecommunications infrastructure, or cyber operations leading to the
destruction of stockpiles of Covid-19 vaccines, could amount to the use of force in
violation of Article 2(4). Similarly, the use of crypto viruses or other forms of digital
sabotage against a State’s financial and banking system, or other operations that cause
widespread economic effects and destabilisation, may amount to the use of force in
violation of Article 2(4).
A cyber operation that severely damages or disables a State’s critical
infrastructure or functions may furthermore be considered as amounting to an armed
attack under international law. Depending on its scale and effect, this may include a
cyber operation that causes an aircraft crash.
4
State responsibility
Key message:
In order for a State to be held internationally responsible for a cyber
operation, the operation has to be attributable to the State under international
law.
A State may also be held responsible under international law if it possesses
knowledge of a cyber operation that is being carried out from its territory and
causing serious adverse consequences with respect to a right of the target State
under international law, and fails to take reasonably available measures to
terminate the cyber operation.
The general rules on State responsibility under international law apply to cyber
operations just as they apply to other activities.
In order for a State to be held responsible for a cyber operation under
international law, it is a condition that the cyber operation is attributable to the State
under international law. 191 Both State and non-State actors conduct cyber operations.
Even if a cyber operation is not conducted by someone acting directly or indirectly
on behalf of a State, the State may nevertheless be held responsible under
international law if it fails to take adequate measures against cyber operations that
target third States from or via its territory.
__________________
190
191
70/142
Tallinn Manual 2.0., commentary to Rule 69, p. 333–337, paras. 9–10.
The condition is set out in Article 2 ILC ASR. The other condition, that the act or omission must
constitute a breach of an international obligation of the State, is dealt with in Section 3.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents