A/76/136
This paper tackles upon some major aspects of international law in relation to
cyberspace. They concern inter-State relations in cyber contexts, given that
international law applies to States and governs the relations between them.
State sovereignty
One of the issues on which discussions need to focus more is the respect for
state sovereignty in the context of cyber operations.
Romania considers that respect for the state sovereignty is an international
obligation per se, the breach of which constitutes an internationally wrongful act;
States have an obligation to respect the sovereignty of other States and refrain from
activities that constitute a violation of their sovereignty; this holds true both in what
concerns the internal as well as the external facet of the principle of sovereignty.
At the same time, we acknowledge that the difficulty in relation to this principle
lies in the absence in cyberspace context of the territoriality and physical
dimensions 208, which are the specific elements of the analysis when dealing with the
sovereignty in the traditional sense.
In relation to these aspects, RO is of the view that cyber operations (conducted
by a State organ or by a person or entity exercising elements of governmental
authority or by a person acting under the instructions of or under the direction or
control of a State) that interferes with or prevents in any way a State from exercising
its (internal and/ or external) sovereign prerogatives (i.e. authority over its territory,
over the property and persons situated therein) constitute a violation of the principle
of State sovereignty and, thus, a breach of international law.
If there is not a State or State endorsed operation one can speak of a criminal
act, which should be investigated and punished in accordance with the criminal law
of the State concerned.
Due diligence principle
The due diligence principle entails that a State may be responsible for the effects
of the conduct of private persons, if it failed to take necessary measures to prevent
those effects 209.
This principle (which implies a certain obligation of conduct on the part of
States) was enunciated by the ICJ in its Corfu Channel judgment 210 emphasizing that
every State is under an “obligation not to allow knowingly its territory to be used for
acts contrary to the rights of other States”.
The due diligence principle requires that States take action in respect of cyber
activities if the following elements are cumulatively met:
the acts are conducted by a non-State actor or a third State) from or through the
territory of the potentially responsible State (or from or through the territory or
cyber infrastructure under its control);
the acts are contrary to the rights of a victim State and have serious adverse
consequences for that State;
the State has actual or constructive knowledge of those acts.
__________________
208
209
210
76/142
The principle refers to protecting the state authority over property and persons within its own
national borders.
ILC’s Articles on State Responsibility, Chapter II, para. 4
Corfu Channel Case (UK v Albania) (Merits) [1949] ICJ Rep 4, 22.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents