provide a light-touch approach to certification and may prove more suitable. EU Cybersecurity Certification Framework The European Union has identified that certification plays a critical role in increasing trust and security in products and services that are crucial for the EU Digital Single Market . At the moment, a number of different security certification schemes for ICT products exist in the EU. For example, smart meter producers currently need to undergo separate certification processes in France, the UK and Germany. Without a common framework for EU-wide valid cybersecurity certificate schemes, the EU identifies an increasing risk of fragmentation and barriers in the single market. In this context, the EU has proposed an EU Certification Framework for ICT security products. The proposed certification framework will provide EU-wide certification schemes as a comprehensive set of rules, technical requirements, standards and procedures. This will be based on agreement at EU level for the evaluation of the security properties of a specific ICT-based product or service e.g. smart cards. ENISA will work towards implementing this certification process. The resulting certificate will be recognised in all Member States, making it easier for businesses to trade across borders and for purchasers to understand the security features of the product or service. While the use of certification will be voluntary for the time being, the framework does avoid multiple certification processes in different Member States and creates an incentive to certify the quality and verify the security of the products and services in question. 144 http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-17-3194_en.htm 145 https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/ eu-cybersecurity-certification-framework 5.3.2 Key Findings – There is a distinct lack of labels to inform end users about IoT device security and risks. However, efforts to create a labelling scheme are under way in various parts of the world. It should be ensured that these schemes are aligned in order to create a level playing field for vendors. – There are as yet no CC cPPs specifically for IoT devices. It should be determined whether these can be generic or specific to application domains. – Non-CC alternatives can provide a light-touch approach to certification and should be explored. 5.4 FUTURE-PROOF LEGISLATION Legislative policy solutions should be sufficiently flexible to deal with societal needs as well as constantly evolving technologies. Regulatory measures for IoT security should make use of inputs from consumers as well as industry representatives on the rights and responsibilities of consumers and vendors. This would help to ensure that the approach taken is effective in the present and fit for the future, and promotes innovation in an efficient way. The introduction of highly stringent measures and legislation by regulators could, counterproductively, prove restrictive for security research; it may be more effective to instead create initiatives to stimulate the development of security by the industry. Besides cybersecurity regulations, liability laws can also effectively drive IoT security; the section on Responsible Industry discusses this point. 5.4.1 Current Landscape and Recent Developments There are only a few legislative efforts aimed at IoT security; we describe these below. It is noted that IoT security is differently organised in different countries, so not every cybersecurity agency is tasked with the same roles and responsibilities. While many industry organisations globally collaborate on a voluntary basis, we found a dearth of initiatives where governments work together for secure IoT. 47

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents