GlobalPlatform defines191 a Secure Element (SE) as a tamper-resistant platform (typically a one-chip secure microcontroller) capable of securely hosting applications and their confidential and cryptographic data (e.g. keys). On the other hand, GlobalPlatform defines a Trusted Execution Environment (TEE)192 as a secure area within a main processor that runs in an isolated environment and guarantees that the code and data loaded within are protected with respect to confidentiality and integrity. Trusted applications running in a TEE have access to the full power of a device's main processor and memory, but hardware isolation protects these components from applications running in the main operating system. Software and cryptographic isolations inside the TEE protect trusted applications from each other. Two common hardware technologies that support TEE are ARM TrustZone and Intel SGX. Synopsys’ DesignWare tRoot Hardware Security Modules (HSMs) also provide a TEE (see www.synopsys.com/dw/ipdir.php?ds=security-troothw-secure-module). In a similar vein, a Trusted Platform Module (TPM)193 is a cryptographic coprocessor that is present in many commercial PCs and servers. The TPM specification is a recommendation from the Trusted Computing Group (TCG) to securely identify individual connected devices and to securely generate and store keys within these devices. However, the inclusion of a TPM in IoT devices does lead to increased costs and resource requirements. Cisco’s implementation of a hardware RoT is the Trust Anchor. Secure Unique Device Identifier (SUDI194) credentials including the a SUDI certificate, the associated 191 https://globalplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Introduction-toSecure-Element-15May2018.pdf 192 https://globalplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Introduction-toTrusted-Execution-Environment-15May2018.pdf 193 https://trustedcomputinggroup.org/work-groups/trusted-platform-module/ 194 https://www.cisco.com/c/dam/en_us/about/doing_business/trust-center/ docs/trust-anchor-technologies-ds-45-734230.pdf key pair, and its entire certificate chain are stored in the tamper resistant Trust Anchor chip. The identity is implemented at manufacturing and chained to a publicly identifiable root Certificate Authority (CA). The hardware chip is used as an anchor for a secure boot process. The Trust Anchor is compliant with NIST specifications and provides a NIST SP 800-90A 195 and B certifiable Random Number Generator (RNG) that extracts entropy from a true random source within the chip. Similar to the Trust Anchor, Google’s Titan security chip196 offers secure boot as well as an end-to-end cryptographic identity system for the servers in Google’s data centres as well as the Pixel mobile phone. The Titan chip's manufacturing process generates unique keying material for each chip, and securely stores this material into a registry database. The contents of this database are cryptographically protected using keys maintained in an offline quorum-based Titan Certification Authority (Titan CA). Individual Titan chips can generate Certificate Signing Requests (CSRs) directed at the Titan CA, which – under the direction of a quorum of Titan identity administrators – can verify the authenticity of the CSRs using the information in the registry database before issuing identity certificates.197 While the chip may not yet offer a practical solution for Class 0-2 IoT devices owing to cost considerations, it does provide a good indicator of the direction of RoT security. Having said that, a general drawback of CA-based approaches is that the CA must be secure and trustworthy; the DigiNotar incident198 has illustrated that CAs may themselves be vulnerable. 195 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NIST_SP_800-90A 196 https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/ titan-in-depth-security-in-plaintext 197 https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/ titan-in-depth-security-in-plaintext 198 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DigiNotar 61

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents