ANNEXES
1. The United Nations Charter, the law
on the use of force (jus ad bellum) and
the principle of non-intervention
The United Nations Charter (UN Charter)
and associated rules of customary
international law apply to activities
conducted in cyberspace. Article 2(3) of
the UN Charter requires States to seek
the peaceful settlement of disputes and
Article 2(4) prohibits the threat or use
of force by a State against the territorial
integrity or political independence
of another State, or in any manner
inconsistent with the purposes of
the UN. These obligations – and the
UN Charter in its entirety – apply in
cyberspace as they do in the physical
realm. They require States to resolve
cyber incidents peacefully without
escalation or resort to the threat or
use of force.
The obligation to seek peaceful
settlement of disputes does not impinge
upon a State’s inherent right to act in
individual or collective self-defence in
response to an armed attack. This right
applies equally in the cyber domain as
it does in the physical realm.
In determining whether a cyber activity
constitutes a use of force, States should
consider whether the activity’s scale
and effects are comparable to traditional
kinetic operations that rise to the level
of use of force under international law.
This involves a consideration of the
intended or reasonably expected direct
and indirect consequences of the cyber
activity, including for example whether
the activity could reasonably be expected
to cause serious or extensive (‘scale’)
damage or destruction (‘effects’) to life,
or injury or death to persons, or result
in damage to the victim State’s objects,
critical infrastructure and/or functioning.
A use of force will be lawful when the
territorial State consents, when it is
authorised by the Security Council
under Chapter VII of the UN Charter, or
when it is taken pursuant to a State’s
inherent right of individual or collective
self-defence in response to an armed
attack, as recognised in Article 51 of
the Charter.
Australia considers that the thresholds
and limitations governing the exercise
of self-defence under Article 51 apply in
respect of cyber activities that constitute
an armed attack and in respect of acts
of self-defence that are carried out by
cyber means. Thus, if a cyber activity –
alone or in combination with a physical
operation – results in, or presents an
imminent threat of, damage equivalent
to a traditional armed attack, then
the inherent right to self-defence is
engaged. Any use of force in self-defence
must be necessary to repel the actual
or imminent armed attack and be a
proportionate response in scope, scale
and duration. Any reliance on Article
51 must be reported directly to the
UN Security Council.
The rapidity of cyber activities, as well
as their potentially concealed and/
or indiscriminate character, raises
new challenges for the application of
established principles. These challenges
have been noted by Australia in
explaining its position on imminence and
the right of self-defence in the context
of national security threats that have
evolved as a result of technological
advances. For example, in a speech to
the University of Queensland in 2017,
then Attorney-General, Senator the Hon.
George Brandis QC, explained that:
97
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents