g implementation and compliance
83
the earliest actions towards change was taken by the Council itself, in the
form of a non-paper written in 1995 by the five permanent members on the
humanitarian impact of sanctions.23
Over time, the Office of the Coordinator for Humanitarian Affairs
(OCHA), sometimes in conjunction with other UN departments, was tasked
with conducting assessments and pre-assessments. There has also been a
steady movement toward standardising humanitarian exemptions (exemptions to allow listed individuals to receive assistance on a case-by-case basis
in response to specific humanitarian needs). This movement was led by the
1267 Committee and was gradually generalised across other sanctions committees over time. All Security Council sanctions since Haiti (1994) have
been targeted, constituting some combination of an arms embargo, travel
and aviation bans, asset freezes and commodity bans.
Few assessments have been made, however, of the potential unintended
consequences of targeted sanctions, and they generally are presumed to have
little direct impact, other than on the individual targets.24 Specifically targeted asset freezes, in fact, have limited impact but broader financial sanctions such as those imposed on Libya in 2011, had economic effects beyond
their original intent. HLR participants discussed the problems associated
with Libyan sanctions on the Central Bank and the petroleum and investment sectors. In this case, UN sectoral sanctions were less targeted than
individual assets freezes and travel bans and had a broader impact.
135. The Council should conduct periodic assessments of the impact of its measures, including in consultation with humanitarian actors and other agencies operating in the field, as well as with the host State, where appropriate. These assessments should be made public.
136. The Security Council should, to the extent possible, commission pre-assessments of the humanitarian and socio-economic effects when contemplating imposition of broad sectoral or financial sanctions.
23
24
S/1995/300, April 1995.
See Targeted Sanctions: The Impact and Effectiveness of UN Action, edited by Thomas
Biersteker, Sue Eckert and Marcos Tourinho, Cambridge University Press, 2015
for a discussion of the unintended consequences of targeted sanctions.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents