Chapter 6 Geopolitics influences threats and interests | CSAN 2021
Means used by state actors: seven categories VIII
Targets of state actors: fifteen categories IX
1. Influencing and interference (including disinformation). This
includes hacking and leaking; covertly influencing individuals,
democratic processes, political decision-making; using
coercion (such as threats, blackmail, extortion or physical
violence) against individuals; influencing and censoring
scientific research.
2. Espionage, both cyber and physical, including economic
espionage.
3. (Cyber) preparatory acts for and actual disruption and
sabotage.
4. Military activities, such as intimidation and show of force
through arms races, large-scale exercises, military
interventions in third countries, deployment of unrecognisable
troops.
5. The use of economic instruments, such as takeovers and
investments, but also the exploitation of strategic
dependencies as a means of exerting economic pressure.
6. Diplomatic and international-political activities, for example,
the use of obstructive power in international forums to block
unwelcome decisions.
7. Legal activities and/or lawfare, in which (inter)national law and
legal systems are used to gain the greatest possible personal
advantage, even if this is very much against the spirit of the
law.
1. Diaspora, i.e. population groups that originate from another
country and are still seen and treated as subjects by the
country of origin.
2. Faith communities.
3. Groups and/or individuals susceptible to polarising messages,
such as groups with strong anti-sentiment (e.g. against the
Dutch government).
4. Targets of opportunity: people who consciously or
unconsciously allow themselves to be used.
5. High potentials: people with the potential to reach knowledge
or influential positions.
6. Institutions and officials of our democratic constitutional state,
at national and local level.
7. Democratic processes, such as elections and referendums.
8. Advisory bodies, which have a role in political decision-making
through research and advice.
9. Educational institutions.
10. Research community, knowledge institutions and think tanks.
11. Civil society, ranging from media to sports associations.
12. International organisations based in the Netherlands.
13. The private sector (and top sectors).
14. Critical national infrastructure (plus suppliers).
15. International frameworks that are crucial for the Netherlands,
such as the EU, NATO and the UN.
The first three categories lend themselves perfectly to the use of
digital resources. Influencing and interference largely take place in
the information domain, which is digitalised in the form of, for
example, online platforms and social media. This facilitates the use
of means of influence such as the creation and/or dissemination of
disinformation, media campaigns, the dissemination of
information to cause damage or harm people, or hack and leak
actions. That the use of digital resources for espionage and
(preparations for) sabotage is perfectly suitable and attractive no
longer needs to be demonstrated. In its 2020 Annual Report, the
AIVD concluded that espionage is a threat to Dutch economic
security.
A prominent target type is the critical national infrastructure,
which includes critical processes, services, suppliers and central
government.X What is striking is that digital sabotage (including
preparatory acts) is mainly used against this type of target. It is
important to note that, as yet, no manifestations of this have been
seen in the Netherlands, but they have been seen in other Western
and even European countries. In particular, there is a growing
interest in exploiting vulnerable links in supply chains. Extensive
digitisation and the limited existence of fall-back options increase
vulnerability.
Back to
Table of Contents
A state actor can use its resources against a wide range of possible
targets: from local associations to international security
organisations and from a single individual to entire communities.
X
The definition of critical national infrastructure is under development. The
description of this target type used here is based on the definition used at the end
of 2019 and included in the Threat Assessment for State Actors from the AIVD,
VIII The order in this box does not imply any ranking of the different means.
MIVD and NCTV. The critical national infrastructure target type has been
IX
A more detailed description of targets and how they are affected can be found in
supplemented with suppliers, because for some years now it has been observed (in
the Threat Assessment for State Actors published by the AIVD, MIVD and NCTV in
the CSAN among others) that suppliers are used as stepping stones to targets
February 2021. The order in this box does not imply any ranking of the different
within the critical national infrastructure. There is a growing interest in exploiting
targets.
vulnerable links in supply chains.
41
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents