Chapter 8 Threat scenarios | CSAN 2021
8 Threat scenarios
The previous chapters address digital threats, resilience and interests that can be in jeopardy
when cyber incidents occur. But what does that mean for you or your organisation? To help
answer that question, this chapter describes three related scenario sections on cloud system
failure and misuse. This particular theme was chosen because of the importance of the cloud
within cyberspace. There has been a large-scale increase in the use of cloud services, which
comes with risks. You can use these scenarios to assess within your organisation whether
events such as those described in the scenario could happen to you, what preparations you
have made and how you can improve your cloud strategy. The scenario was prepared by TNO
on behalf of the NCTV.
Cloudburst scenario
This scenario has three scenario parts that follow each other but
can also be read separately.
Scenario part a: the Cloud comes back online quickly
Description of events
Extreme weather causes major problems in the Netherlands. Heavy
flooding occurs at several locations and is accompanied by power
outages. As a result, Nubes Link-Exchange (NLeX)XI, a major cloud
exchange provider, is experiencing significant disruption to its
connection to one of the Dutch data centres of Cirrocumulus
NetworksXII, a major cloud service provider (CSP). NLeX provides
direct, private connections between customers (governments and
businesses) and the Cirrocumulus Networks cloud network,
without the intervention of an Internet Service Provider (ISP). Due
to the malfunction at NLeX, none of the customers in the affected
region will be able to connect directly to their Cirrocumulus
Networks cloud environment.
Some of the affected organisations are prepared for such a
temporary unavailability and have taken extra (fallback)
connectivity services as laid down in their contract with NLeX and
Cirrocumulus Networks. This part of the affected organisations will
be switched via NLeX from the direct connection to Cirrocumulus
Networks to a connection via the (public) Internet, provided by an
Internet Service Provider (ISP). There is hardly any disruption for
these organisations. The other part of the affected organisations
have not purchased any additional (fallback) services and
temporarily lose the connection to their cloud environment as
provided by Cirrocumulus Networks. After appropriate action by
NLeX, their services can be resumed after about two hours.
The impact of the temporary system failure varies per affected
organisation, as it depends on the set-up of their infrastructure
(variations in the use of public, (virtual) private, hybrid cloud and
on-premises solutions). Organisations with a lot of on-premises
infrastructure are less affected by the system failure than those
whose services are housed in the cloud environment.
Interpretation
In recent years, more and more parties have opted for a direct
connection to the cloud environment that does not go through the
public Internet but connects them to the Cloud as directly as
possible (with as few parties as possible in between). Reasons for
choosing this are speed (less delay), confidentiality and reliability
(fewer links). Practical examples include cloud connectivity services
Direct Connect (AWS) and Express Route (Microsoft). In all cases, it
is important to consider how dependent an organisation wants to
be on a cloud service provider and what the risks and benefits are
for your organisational processes. These are important
considerations when deciding on your own cloud strategy.
Organisations that work a lot with sensitive information often
XI
Any resemblance to an existing company is purely coincidental and not intended.
XII Any resemblance to an existing company is purely coincidental and not intended.
49
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents