A/76/136
Right of Self-Defence
6.
While Singapore considers the above principles to be essential ones
underpinning the international legal order, Singapore’s position is that it bears noting
that ultimately, none of these impair a State’s inherent right of self-defence, as
provided under the UN Charter. This right of self-defence also applies in the cyber
domain. In other words, a State has the inherent right of self-defence if malicious
cyber activity amounting to an armed attack, or an imminent threat thereof, occurs
against that State.
7.
Malicious cyber activity attributable to a State that causes death, injury, physical
damage or destruction equivalent to a traditional non-cyber armed attack, or
presenting an imminent threat thereof, would constitute an armed attack. Singapore
notes the increasing prevalence of this view amongst States.
8.
In Singapore’s view, it is also possible that, in certain limited circumstances,
malicious cyber activity may amount to an armed attack even if it does not necessarily
cause death, injury, physical damage or destruction, taking into account the scale and
effects of the cyber activity. An example might be a targeted cyber operation causing
sustained and long-term outage of Singapore’s critical infrastructure.
9.
A series or combination of cyber-attacks, whether or not it is in combination
with kinetic attacks, may amount to an armed attack, even if the individual attacks do
not reach the threshold equivalent to an armed attack, as long as the attacks are
launched by the same actor or by different attackers acting in concert.
Internationally Wrongful Act
10. Even if malicious cyber activity against a State has not risen to the level of an
armed attack entitling the victim State to exercise the right of self-defence,
international law provides that a victim State that is subjected to another State’s
internationally wrongful act against it (whether through malicious cyber activity, or
physical means) is entitled to have recourse to counter-measures which are consistent
with international law.
11. Malicious cyber activity attributable to a State that interferes with a victim
State’s proper governing functions is an example of an internationally wrongful act.
12. Apart from counter-measures, a victim State that is subject to malicious cyber
activity short of an internationally wrongful act may also respond with acts of
retorsion.
13. Singapore’s view is that the obligation of all States to settle their international
disputes by peaceful means, in such a manner that international peace and security
are not endangered, remains a key principle underpinning the international legal
order.
Due Diligence
14. There is a need for more clarity on the scope and practical applications, if any,
of due diligence in cyberspace. Issues such as the threshold required to trigger an
obligation on States to act or respond, the degree of knowledge required of States,
and the measures expected of a State from which the malicious cyber activity
originates, are some examples of the questions that need to be further discussed and
addressed among States.
84/142
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents