Civil Nuclear Cyber Security Strategy 2022
3. Sector Maturity and Challenges
To assess the gap between current civil nuclear cyber security and our goal, we conducted a
comprehensive gap analysis across the sector. This gathered both quantitative and qualitative
data from businesses, the nuclear supply chain, the NCSC and the ONR to identify the major
challenges and strengths facing the sector currently, and across the next five years.
3.1 Civil Nuclear Cyber Maturity Benchmarking Assessment
In 2020/21 BEIS used the maturity framework referred to in Figure 6 to conduct a Cyber
Maturity Benchmarking Assessment across the civil nuclear sector. Chief Information Security
Officers (CISOs) responsible for cyber security in nuclear sector organisations assessed
themselves across the different criteria, and those results were overlaid by the regulator with
their independent regulatory intelligence. This allowed us to look at areas of perceived strength
or weakness and aggregate this data from individual organisations to build a sector-wide view.
We were also able to compare organisational and regulatory assessments, and look at
consistency across the range of scores for individual outcomes.
The assessment highlighted variation in maturity across domains, with regulated domains
showing greater maturity than those which were unregulated and OT security being
comparatively weaker than IT. The summary report outlined 13 recommendations as set out in
Figure 8.
The Cyber Maturity Benchmarking Assessment provided both a quantitative assessment of
sector maturity which can be used to assess strengths and weaknesses, and a baseline for
sector maturity to measure progress against. This CAF-aligned framework will be used twice
more during the lifetime of this strategy to assess progress, with the second of these iterations
inputting into decision-making for future work.
Figure 8 – A summary of the recommendations from the Civil Nuclear Cyber Maturity
Benchmarking Assessment
RECOMMENDATIONS
1
Focus future cyber improvement initiatives on the areas identified for further development by the Cyber Maturity
Benchmarking Assessment
2
Further strengthen the approach to information sharing on cyber (e.g. threat intelligence, good practices) and
collaboration on cyber security within the sector
3
Continue to support the annual technical cyber exercise programme but also seek to develop a mature cyber
incident response exercise programme
4
Support dutyholders to deliver regular, tailored cyber incident response exercises within their organisations in
order to drive improvements and strengthen the maturity of their cyber incident response and recovery plans
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents