A/76/136
position paper therefore refers only to that part of the digital space which concerns
the security dimension. Part I addresses questions concerning international law in
general including human rights. Part II places particular emphasis on questions
relating to international humanitarian law (IHL).
Switzerland is committed to building and maintaining a free, open, secure and
peaceful cyberspace, and to advancing the recognition, observance and enforcement
of international law in this space. 213 All states have a common interest in ensuring
that cyberspace is governed by the rule of law and used for peaceful purposes only.
Switzerland considers international law to be applicable to cyberspace. It therefore
welcomes the consensus of previous UN GGEs that international law, and in
particular the UN Charter in its entirety, are applicable to cyberspace 214 – which was
also approved unanimously by the UN General Assembly. 215 It also welcomes the
OEWG 2019/2021 report of 18 March 2021, which confirms this consensus. 216
Switzerland views national positions of states as an important contribution to
fleshing out the application of international law in cyberspace. This paper therefore
gives an overview of Switzerland’s position, but is neither exhaustive nor conclusive.
Continuing intergovernmental exchange at multilateral level remains key in order to
continue to clarify how international law is applicable to cyberspace in concrete
terms. A definitive assessment of a cyber incident in terms of international law is only
possible when the concrete circumstances are known. This means interpreting and
applying the rules set out below in each individual case.
Of particular importance to the context of cybersecurity are namely the rules of
international law described below.
I.
General international law
1.
Peaceful settlement of disputes
In accordance with Art. 2 para. 3 and Art. 33 of the UN Charter, disputes which
may endanger the maintenance of international peace and security should be settled
by peaceful means. This includes diplomatic proceedings, arbitration or recourse to
the International Court of Justice (ICJ). As a neutral country with long-standing
experience and engagement in the provision of good offices, Switzerland is
committed to upholding this principle in cyberspace, emphasising the overriding aim
of ensuring that cyberspace is used for peaceful purposes only. Switzerland therefore
welcomes the UN GGE’s 2015 report and the OEWG 2019/2021 report confirming
the peaceful settlement of disputes as one of the UN Charter’s central principles,
which is also applicable to cyberspace. Consequently, disputes in cyberspace should
also be settled by peaceful means, not with unilateral measures.
2.
Sovereignty
Sovereignty is a foundational principle of international law. It refers to a state’s
jurisdiction to define, apply and enforce its own legal order, which in principle is
limited to its territory. At interstate level however, sovereignty implies an independent
and equal co-existence among states. Respect for and protection from interference
__________________
213
214
215
216
86/142
See Switzerland’s Foreign Policy Strategy 2021–23, Objective 4.4 and Switzerland’s Digital
Foreign Policy Strategy 2021–24, Chapter 4.3.
See Group of Governmental Experts on Developments in the Field of Information and
Telecommunications in the Context of International Security, 2013 Report (2013 Report, UN
Doc. A/68/98, para. 19; 2015 Report (UN Doc. A/70/174), para. 24, para. 28 c).
Resolution A/70/237.
See Open-ended Working Group on Developments in the Field of Information and
Telecommunications in the Context of International Security, 2021 report, para. 8, UN Doc.
A/75/816.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents