A/76/136
B. The Concept of “Due Diligence”
In recent public statements on how international law applies in cyberspace, a
few States have referenced the concept of “due diligence”: that States have a general
international law obligation to take steps to address activity emanating from their
territory that is harmful to other States, and that such a general obligation applies
more specifically, as a matter of international law, to cyber activities. The United
States has not identified the State practice and opinio juris that would support a claim
that due diligence currently constitutes a general obligation under international law.
We do believe, however, that if a State is notified of harmful activity emanating from
its territory it must take reasonable steps to address such activity.
C. State responsibility for internationally wrongful acts
Both the 2013 and 2015 GGE reports concluded that States must meet their
international obligations regarding internationally wrongful acts attributable to them
under international law. 293 In addition, they must not use proxies to commit
internationally wrongful acts using ICTs. 294
Under the law of State responsibility, a State is responsible for an
internationally wrongful act when there is an act or omission that is attributable to it
under international law that constitutes a breach of an international obligation of the
State. Cyber activities may therefore constitute internationally wrongful acts under
the law of State responsibility if they are inconsistent with an international obligation
of the State and are attributable to it.
The law of State responsibility supplies the standards for attributing acts,
including cyber acts, to States. For example, cyber operations conducted by organs of
a State or by persons or entities empowered by domestic law to exercise elements of
governmental authority are attributable to that State. As important, as a legal matter,
States cannot escape responsibility for internationally wrongful cyber acts by
perpetrating them through proxies; cyber operations conducted by non-State actors
are attributable to a State under the law of State responsibility when such operations
are engaged in pursuant to the State’s instructions or under the State’s direction or
control, or when the State later acknowledges and adopts the operations as its own.
Thus, when there is information – whether obtained through technical means or allsource intelligence – that permits attribution of a cyber act of an ostensibly non-State
actor to a State under the international law of State responsibility, the victim State has
all of the rights and remedies against the responsible State permitted to it under
international law.
The law of State responsibility does not set forth burdens or standards of proof
for attribution. Such questions may be relevant for judicial or other types of
proceedings, but they do not apply as an international legal matter to a State’s
determination about attribution of internationally wrongful cyber acts for purposes of
its response to such acts, including by taking unilateral, self-help measures
permissible under international law, such as countermeasures. In that context, a State
acts as its own judge of the facts and may make a unilateral determination with respect
to attribution of a cyber operation to another State. Absolute certainty is not required.
Instead, international law generally requires that States act reasonably under the
circumstances. Similarly, there is no international legal obligation to reveal evidence
on which attribution is based. But to facilitate global understanding of emerging state
practice in this rapidly developing area, public attributions should, wherever feasible,
include sufficient evidence to allow corroboration or cross-checking of allegations.
__________________
293
294
21-09670
2013 GGE Report, para. 23; 2015 GGE Report, para. 28(f)
2013 GGE Report, para. 23; 2015 GGE Report, para. 28(e).
141/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents