The Supreme Court of the Republic of Korea has taken a similar position to that of the United
States, stating that:
“In principle, illegally obtained evidence is not admissible and accordingly,
such evidence cannot be used as an evidence to prove guilt of the criminal
defendant.”
The Court went on to say:
“In order to render a final determination of admissibility of illegally obtained
seized item, comprehensive consideration should be given to the issue of
whether or not violation made by investigative agencies impedes substantial
contents of due process by taking into account following factors including 1) the
substances and degrees of investigative agency’s violations, 2) the intention of
investigative agency, 3) natures and the extent of the infringement of rights or
legal interests protected by procedure rules, and so on.”
Case 2.10: Customs Evasions Case (Korea)39
Korean law enforcement agents searched the offices of Company A on suspicion of tariff
evasion by lowering unit cost for importation, seizing documents and electronic data. In the
process for the search and seizure, documents and electronic data pertaining to Company
B—not specified in the warrant—were also seized. On the basis of the seized information,
Company B was subsequently charged after it was confirmed that Company B had evaded
tariffs in the same manner as Company A based.
The Supreme Court of Korea subsequently excluded the evidence on the basis that, first, the
evidence was not collected in accordance with the procedures as set forth in the Constitution
and Criminal Procedure Act, and, second, the secondary evidence failed to follow legal
procedures for the protection of fundamental human rights: in principle, the Court ruled,
secondary evidence cannot be admitted as evidence to prove guilt. The Court provided
that “[d]ocuments and electronic data relating to Company B which were seized, along with
seizure of those pertaining to Company A, were neither the object to be seized as stipulated
by a search and seizure warrant nor related to the facts of suspicion.”
The Court further censured the investigators lack of discrimination between data and device,
noting that “[a]fter moving the storage device itself into the office of the investigative agency,
and then investigating the electronic information related to facts of suspicion, either the
process of printing the concerned electronic information into documents or the process of
Page 100 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents