Software analysis can also be important to determine if software is produced solely for committing
crimes or can be used for legitimate as well as illegal purposes (dual use). This differentiation can
be relevant, insofar as some countries limit criminalization of the production of illegal devices to
those that are either solely or primarily designed to commit crimes. Data-related investigations
are not confined to the software function, but also include analysis of non-executable files such
as pdf-documents or video files. File analysis also includes the examination of digital documents
that might have been forged46 as well as metadata investigation.47 Such analysis can determine the
time48 the document was last opened or modified.49 Furthermore, metadata analysis can be used to
identify the author of a file containing a threatening message, or the serial number of the camera
that was used to produce a child-pornography image. Authors can also be identified based on
linguistic analysis, which can assist in determining if the suspect has written articles before and left
information that can help identification in this context.50
As investigators must focus on relevant evidence in order to prevent inadmissibility, special
attention must be given to identifying relevant evidence,51 meaning that forensic experts play an
important role in the design of investigation strategies and the selection of relevant evidence.
They can, for example, determine the location of relevant evidence on large storage systems.
This enables investigators to limit the scope of the investigation to those parts of the computer
infrastructure that are relevant for the investigation and avoid inappropriate and large-scale seizure
of computer hardware.52 This selection process is relevant as various types of storage devices are
available that can make identification of the storage location of relevant evidence challenging.53
This is especially valid if the suspect is not storing information locally but uses means of remote
storage. Forensic analysis can then be used to determine if remote-storage services were used.54
Identification of relevant digital information is not confined to files themselves. Databases of
software tools that are made available by operating systems to quickly identify files might contain
relevant information too. Another example of evidence identification is the involvement of forensic
experts in determining the right procedural instruments. A number of countries enable lawenforcement agencies to carry out two types of real-time observations—the collection of traffic
data in real time, and the interception of content data in real time. In general, the interception of
content data is more intrusive than the collection of traffic data. Forensic experts can determine
whether the collection of traffic data is sufficient to prove the committing of a crime, and thereby
help investigators to strike the right balance between the need to collect effective evidence and
the obligation to protect the rights of the suspect by choosing the least intensive instrument out of
the group of equally effect options. Both examples show that the role of forensic investigators is not
restricted to the technical aspects of an investigation, but includes a responsibility for protecting the
suspect’s fundamental rights and thereby avoiding inadmissibility of the evidence collected.
II. Collecting Evidence with the Assistance of Third Parties
Page 102 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents