countries, notification must be made prior to data acquisition if the communication record is
collected through a court order rather than through a search and seizure warrant.
As communication content, the final type of third-party stored communication, is the most sensitive
form of communications, a search and seizure warrant is invariably required, meaning that the
request must make a showing that the desired information is necessary to clarify the “probable
cause” relating the object of the search and crime. Here, the procedural law should consider
whether all categories of stored content deserve the same kinds of protection. For example, there
is a lower expectation of privacy for information in cloud storage as opposed to the contents of
an email. Therefore, a full search warrant may be appropriate for emails, whereas only a grand jury
subpoena or a court order may be appropriate for cloud-stored information.
Cooperation with the private sector, discussed further on, is an essential element to combatting
cybercrime (see section 6 C, below). With respect to the present discussion, it bears noting that
ISPs, in particular, potentially play an especially important role in many cybercrime investigation
as, in many cases they have the technical capability to detect and prevent crimes to support lawenforcement agencies. That assistance is especially relevant in connection with identifying suspects.
Obligations discussed range from the mandatory implementation of prevention technology to
voluntary support of investigations.57 Cooperation between law-enforcement agencies and ISPs
requires the application of certain procedures.58
One example is the forensic tool CIPAV (Computer and Internet Protocol Address Verifier), which
was used in the United States to identify a suspect who had been using anonymous communication
services.59 Another example of cooperation between ISPs and investigators is email investigation.
Emails have become a very popular means of communication.60 To avoid identification, offenders
sometimes use free email addresses which they were able to register using fake personal
information. However, even in this case, examination of header information61 and log-files of the
email provider will in some instances enable identification of the suspect.
The need to cooperate and communicate with providers is not limited to ISPs. Since some
crimes such as phishing62 and the commercial distribution of child pornography include financial
transactions, one strategy to identify the offender is to obtain data from financial institutions
involved in the transactions.63 In Germany, for example, investigators worked with credit-card
companies to analyze and identify customers who had purchased child pornography on a specific
website.64 Such investigations are more challenging when anonymous payment methods are used,65
such as bitcoin.66
Law enforcement often require third-parties to provide communications in real-time. Such is
particularly true where there are indications of imminent perpetration or harm, especially in cases of
terrorism, and where real-time collection may offer critical evidence. Furthermore, some information
can only be captured in real-time as it is never stored (instead existing only in the “cloud”). The
communication record (the second class of information) can be had in real-time by monitoring
current IP addresses of transmitters and receivers, thereby helping to geolocate suspects. Such
Page 104 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents