Distributed databases, by which data is copied, maintained and distributed across servers in various
locations, therein offering greater safety and security, complicate localization of data. Through the
use of a centralized distributed database management system (DDBMS), the data is synchronized
and integrated logically, allowing the user to manage it as if it were all stored in the same location.
Distributed databases can be either homogenous or heterogeneous. In a homogenous system, all
of the physical locations have the same underlying hardware and run the same operating systems
and database applications, while in a heterogeneous system, the hardware, operating systems
or database applications may vary at each of the locations. Together with the use of a technique
known as “sharding”—a type of database partitioning by which large databases are separated
into smaller, more manageable parts called data shards—, accessing comprehensible information
can be quite challenging, both for law enforcement and for hackers. Mutual legal assistance
treaties (MLATs) facilitate extra-jurisdictional requests for data (see section 3 A, below), and can be
particularly useful in these circumstances.68 Where a service provider utilizes a foreign cloud data
center (e.g., Amazon Web Services), the data frequently resides in a country other than where the
service provider is registered.
Notwithstanding the fact that data might be fragmented and stored in several servers, and identical
copies may co-exist simultaneously in different places, it is often possible to retrieve that data
intact by relying on service providers’ control of the cloud service mechanism. As such, in a spin on
traditional understanding, the user’s account together with the name and the headquarter address
of the cloud service provider is designated as the “place” subjected to search and seizure rather
than a physical location. The US DoJ has provided examples of how a search and seizure warrant
against an email account might be prepared.69 Consequently, the execution of a search and seizure
warrant in cloud computing environments depends on service providers that control the locations
and methods for data storage. The execution of a search and seizure warrant in cloud computing
environments is conducted by when law enforcement present the warrant to service providers.
Execution of a search and seizure warrant in cloud computing environments can be compared to
general forms of search and seizure that require direct participation of investigative authorities.
An account in the cloud subjected to search and seizure may be designated differently depending
on the internet source used by the offenders: for instance, if webmail is used, the mail account is
designated as the one to be seized; when a web drive is used, the URL address is designated for
seizure; if web hosting servers are being used, then those IP addresses are selected for seizure.
B. Jurisdictional Complications to Search & Seizures
While developing technology complicates procedural aspects of search and seizure, more
fundamental issues arise over jurisdictional conflicts. Although the question of jurisdiction is
discussed in greater depth hereafter (see section 2 E, below), it bears raising the topics here
specifically with regard to procedural matters. Cloud computing has particularly complicated
Page 106 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents