CHAPTER 2
E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Introduction
121
I. The Traditional Notion of Jurisdiction
122
II. Adaptive Jurisdiction Principles
123
A. Principle of Territoriality
123
B. Principle of (Active) Nationality
124
C. Principle of Passive Nationality
124
D. Protective Principle
125
E. Principle of Universal Jurisdiction
126
III. National Frameworks
126
A. Adaptive Legislative Jurisdictional Definitions
126
B. Informal Cooperation
127
IV. Multilateral Instruments
128
Conclusion
128
Introduction
The inherently transnational and cross-border nature of cybercrime renders investigating
cybercrimes and prosecuting cybercriminals much more difficult than traditional crimes,
largely due to the unique jurisdictional obstacles. Unlike their physical world analogs,
cybercrimes can be committed from virtually anywhere on the globe, with attacks
directed against targets in virtually any part of the world, and with effects potentially
being felt by people the world over. For these reasons, states have found it necessary
to reach beyond the territorial tethers that have been traditionally used to define
sovereignty. While it is important to make space for the theoretical underpinnings to
accordingly adapt to cyberspace, at the same time that increasingly-exerted ability of a
targeted state to reach offenders beyond its territory must be balanced with respect for
the sovereignty of other states.
Jurisdiction, understood in its basic sense as the official power to make legal decisions and
judgments,1 is a multi-faceted notion. Fundamentally, a state’s jurisdiction is understood as
being composed of three different authorities:
Page 121 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents