52. As indicated in appendix 9 C, 196
countries are targeted. As of 2
October 2015, approximately 76.0%
(149 countries) have domestic law that
comprehensively or partially governs
cybercrime irrespective of having draft
law on cybercrime. Specifically, 137
countries adopted domestic law that
holistically or partly covers cybercrime,
and another 12 countries had or have
a draft law that deals with cybercrime,
along with having other laws that address
cybercrime. Further, 12 countries had or
have a draft cybercrime law in progress.
However, 33 countries have no domestic
legislation pertaining to cybercrime, while
2 countries have no data to assess their
legislative statuses.
53. Examples of domestic law concerning
cybercrime whose name explicitly uses
the term “cybercrime” can be found in,
among others, Botswana, Cybercrime
and Computer Related Crimes, 2007 and
Philippines, Cybercrime Prevention Act,
(2012).
54. See Russia: Criminal Code, ch. 28, Crimes
in the Sphere of Computer Information, at
http://www.wipo.int/edocs/lexdocs/laws/
en/ru/ru006en.pdf.
55. A list of domestic legislation regarding
concerning cybercrime whose name
provides the term similar to “cybercrime”
includes, but is not limited to, Antigua
and Barbuda: Electronic Crimes Act,
(2013); Sri Lanka: Computer Crime
Act, (2007); Bahrain: Law concerning
Information Technology Crimes, (2014);
and Dominican Republic: Law on High
Technology Crimes, (2007).
56. See, e.g., China: Criminal Law, (2016),
Art. 286 (“Whoever, in violation of State
regulations, cancels, alters, increases
or jams the functions of the computer
information system, thereby making it
impossible for the system to operate
normally, if the consequences are
serious, shall be sentenced to fixedterm imprisonment of not more than
five years or criminal detention.”). See,
e.g., Abhishek Pratap Singh, “China’s
First Cyber Security Law,” Institute
for Defense Studies and Analyses,
(23 Dec. 2016), at http://www.idsa.in/
backgrounder/china-first-cyber-securitylaw_apsingh_231216#footnote5_w4sr2kl.
57. See, e.g., Oman: Royal Decree Issuing
the Cyber Crime Law, (2011), which states
that “cybercrime refers to crimes referred
to in this law,” at http://www.qcert.org/
sites/default/files/public/documents/
om-ecrime-issuing_the_cyber_crime_laweng-2011.pdf.
Page 140 | Chapter 2 | End Notes
58. See, e.g., Kosovo: Law on Prevention and
Fight of the Cyber Crime (2010), Art. 3,
which defines “cybercrime” as a criminal
activity carried out in a network that has
as objective or as a way of carrying out
the crime, misuse of computer systems
and computer data, at http://www.
kuvendikosoves.org/common/docs/
ligjet/2010-166-eng.pdf.
59. ITU Understanding Cybercrime, supra § 1
B, note 1, at 12.
60. UNODC Cybercrime Study supra § 1 C,
note 7, at 11.
61. CIS Agreement provides that “offences
against computer information” is
defined as a criminal act of which
target is computer information. Supra
note 33, at Art. 1(a). See also Budapest
Convention, supra § 1 B, note 32; AU
Convention, supra note 48; and the
Directive on Fighting Cyber Crime within
Economic Community of West African
States [hereafter, “ECOWAS Directive”],
at https://ccdcoe.org/sites/default/
files/documents/ECOWAS-110819FightingCybercrime.pdf.
62. See SCO, Agreement between the
Governments of the Member States of
the SCO on Cooperation in the Field of
International Information Security (2009)
[hereafter, “SCO Agreement”], Art. 2., at
http://www.ccdcoe.org/sites/default/files/
documents/SCO-090616-IISAgreement.
pdf (considering “information crime”
as one of the major threats in the field
of ensuring international information
security); Annex 1, ibid. (stating that
“information crime” means use of and/
or attack on information resources in the
information space for illegal purposes).
63. CIS Agreement, supra note 47.
64. See SCO Agreement, supra note 62.
65. OAS provides that “For the purposes of
this diagnosis, ‘cybercrime’ is defined as
a criminal activity in which information
technology systems (including, inter
alia, telecommunications and computer
systems) are the corpus delicti or means
of committing an offense.” Final Report
of the Second Meeting of Government
Experts on Cyber Crime, (2000), OAS,
p. 2, at http://www.oas.org/juridico/
english/cybGE_IIrep.pdf (in English).
See also Thomas Weigend, Preparatory
Colloquium for the 20th International
Congress of Penal Law on “Information
Society and Penal Law” (organized by
AIDP), § I (Criminal Law, General Part),
§ 1: Concept paper and questionnaire,
(2012), AIDP, p. 1 (articulating that “The
term ‘cybercrime’ is understood to cover
criminal conduct that affects interests
associated with the use of information
and communication technology (ICT)
(emphasis added) [….]. The common
denominator and characteristic feature of
all cybercrime offences and cybercrime
investigation can be found in their relation
to computer systems, computer networks
and computer data (emphasis added)
[….]”), at http://www.penal.org/IMG/pdf/
Section_I_EN.pdf.
66. David Wall, “Cybercrimes: New Wine, No
Bottles?,” in Pamela Davies, Peter Francis
& Victor Jupp (eds.), Invisible Crimes:
Their Victims and their Regulation, (New
York: Macmillan, 1999). See also Peter
N. Grabosky, “Virtual Criminality: Old
Wine in New Bottles?,” Social & Legal
Studies, Vol. 10 (2001), p. 243 (adapting
the phrase be more of a matter of “old
wine in new bottles”). The origin of the
phrase is Biblical: “No one sews a piece
of unshrunk cloth on an old cloak, for the
patch pulls away from the cloak, and a
worse tear is made. Neither is new wine
put into old wineskins; otherwise, the
skins burst, and the wine is spilled, and
the skins are destroyed; but new wine
is put into fresh wineskins, and so both
are preserved.” The Bible, Mat. 9:16–17
(NRSV).
67. Ian Walden, Computer Crimes and Digital
Investigations (2d ed.), (Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 2016), para. 2.27.
68. Anne Flanagan, “The Law and Computer
Crime: Reading the Script of Reform,”
International Journal of Law & Information
Technology, Vol. 13, Issue1 (2005), pp.
98–117.
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents