The other key area to be reflected in national legislation are the safeguards accompanying the criminal sanctions. Although these are discussed more at length in greater depth in the sections 4 A and 4 B, below, it bears highlighting here that ensuring that fundamental rights are protected is as important as criminalizing certain behaviors. Fundamental freedom requiring protection include (A) due process, (B) privacy and data and (C) freedom of expression. A. General Due Process Considerations A number of procedural issues related to investigations and prosecutions are considered in section 2 C; other issues related to due process, such as the rights of the accused to counsel and to being present in connection with certain digital investigations. A vast area for consideration, the Toolkit does not exhaustively deal with the full range of due process issues related generally to criminal law; rather it focuses on specific issues related to cybercrime. B. Privacy & Data Protection According to UNODC, almost all responding countries indicated that existing privacy protections extended to computer data and electronic communications.60 A balance is struck by protecting the privacy of personal data collected and processed by third parties, while allowing, in exceptional circumstances, that these third parties could be obliged to make disclosures to law enforcement.61 C. Freedom of Expression Freedom of expression must be taken into account in criminalizing the dissemination of information via computer systems or cyberspace either because the underlying content is illegal (e.g., child pornography, or because the actor is unauthorized to do so (e.g., copyright).62 Relatedly, the responsibility of facilitators (e.g., ISPs) must be taken into account, with many countries limiting liability.63 Conclusion There is a diversity of ways in which states have defined, criminalized and instituted procedural, evidentiary, jurisdictional and institutional aspects in fight against cybercrime. This section has highlighted just a few of the very many options by which national substantive law has criminalized various cybercrimes, with selection being based on good practices and with an eye to furthering international interoperability. In addition to appropriately empowering authorities to combat cybercrime, it is important to ensure that corresponding safeguards—notably for due process, privacy and data and freedom of expression—are also implemented. Page 167 | Chapter 3 | § A. Substantive Law Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents