where techniques include hacking and surveilling individuals’ electronic devices.13 Lastly, bulk-data
collection is permitted for the purpose of acquiring intelligence relating to individuals beyond the
UK territorial border, as long as a warrant is issued.
Oversight for the Act, and thus for the releasing of these vast and intrusive powers, is controlled
through what is called a “double-lock”; that “double-lock” requires a warrant to be approved by
both government ministers and the specially-created judicial panel called the Investigatory Powers
Commission.14 In case of urgency, a warrant can be issued without the Commission’s involvement
insofar as it is subject to review by the Commission within three working days.15 Already a heavily
surveilled population,16 UK authorities are now, along with Chinese and Russian authorities, a
“global leader” in bulk surveillance of its citizens.17
Among other jurisdictions, Korean law guarantees the right of the defendant to participate
in the search and seizure of an information storage device such as a computer. For example,
Articles 121 & 122 of the Korean Criminal Procedure Act provide as follows:
“A prosecutor, the criminal defendant, or his/her defense counsel may be present
when a warrant of seizure or of search is being executed. Where a warrant of
seizure or of search is to be executed, the persons listed in the preceding Article
shall be notified of the date and place of execution in advance. [...T]his shall
not apply in cases where a person prescribed in the preceding Article, clearly
expresses his/her will in advance to the court that he/she does not desire to be
present or in case of urgency.”
The Korean Supreme Court has strictly interpreted the above provisions, ruling that the seizure and
search procedure of information storage device was illegal for failing to guarantee the participation
right of those subject to seizure in the review procedure conducted after taking out information
storage device.18
Case 4.1: United States v. Ulbricht (“Silk Road”) (USA)19
On 29 May 2015, a Manhattan federal court somewhat controversially20 sentenced Ross
William Ulbricht to life in prison in connection with his operation and ownership of Silk Road
between January 2011 and October 2013.21 Silk Road was a hidden “darkweb” website
that enabled users to buy and sell illegal drugs and other unlawful goods and services
anonymously and beyond the reach of law enforcement;22 the black market was designed “as
an online utopia beyond law enforcement’s reach”.23
During the court proceedings, Ulbricht claimed that, although he had initially been involved
in the site, and although he even averred that illicit activities may have been conducted
Page 174 | Chapter 4 | § A. Due Process
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents