equation discussed above; illegitimate efforts to repress expression in the name of security could have deleterious effects on internet usage for legitimate purposes.45 The internet thrives on the open exchange of information—that is, the so-called “marketplace of ideas”—which, in equal measure, requires both access to information and freedom of expression.46 For example, innovation, and the incentive to innovate, depends on striking an appropriate balance between providing access to information, on the one hand, and rewarding inventors by protecting intellectual property rights, on the other. Rapid cyber and ICT developments have allowed the internet to be a particularly powerful driver of economic, social and even political changes. Those changes have been accompanied by a wide array of legal and regulatory initiatives, some of which indirectly or even unintentionally place limits on the right to communicate but which nonetheless may have a chilling effect on expression.47 For example, governments frequently regulate access to certain content in order to reduce criminal activity. In other circumstances, it is possible that governments have incidentally criminalized online expression by failing to keep laws regulating broadcasting current with technological developments.48 A recent study by UNESCO on the issue of preserving online freedom of expression advocated promoting a balance between security and expression. According to that study, governments should take a pragmatic approach that minimizes online restrictions yet which addresses issues arising out of legitimate societal values.49 Such an approach helps to ensure a vibrant future of the internet, preserving its role as a place for the exchange of ideas that has made it such a unique and powerful platform for economic, social and political progress. Conclusion In designing and implementing legal frameworks to combat cybercrime, states should reconcile the different interests that are to be protected. Although data protection/privacy and security may be construed as competing, even mutually-exclusive concerns, there is a rich body of international good practices showing that, at minimum, the privileging of one need not result in the significant diminution of the other. In any case, where one right is curtailed, it should be done on the basis of the principle of proportionality. If a state compiles, stores, uses or discloses personal information— for example, in a police register—, such interference or intrusion into a person’s private life should meet certain conditions under law, that respect due process and re-enforce the “trust” principle by being both proportionate to the legitimate aims pursued and necessary. To ensure that the internet’s full potential is reached, and in order to avoid having a chilling effect on communication— both in personal expression, and in the seeking and acquiring of information—, the laws and their application, whether inadvertently or purposefully, must be kept open and pragmatic. Page 188 | Chapter 4 | § B. Data Protection & the Right to Communicate Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents