CHAPTER 5
A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border
Cooperation
Table of Contents
Introduction
194
I. Multilateral Treaties on Cybercrime
196
A. Budapest Convention
196
B. Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement
197
C. Shanghai Cooperation Organization Agreement
197
D. League of Arab States Convention on Combating Information Technology Offences
198
E. African Union Convention on Cyber Security and Personal Data Protection
198
F. Areas of Improvement for Formal International Agreements
198
II. Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties
199
A. General Aspects of MLATs
199
B. Budapest Convention’s MLA Provisions
202
III. Extradition Treaties
202
A. General Aspects of Extradition Treaties
203
B. Budapest Convention’s Extradition Provisions
203
Conclusion
204
Introduction
The global, trans-national, cross-border nature of cyberspace raises substantial
jurisdictional issues (see section 2 E, above). Operating from a Westphalian nation-state
concept of sovereignty, states—and their territorially-based cybercrime legislation—have
been “plagued” by the boundary-defying fluidity of cyberspace and of cybercrime.1
Further, different legal systems, with their own unique anomalies and idiosyncrasies,
often present major obstacles to countries seamlessly and effectively fighting cybercrime
across borders.
Although there are a number of offences that can be prosecuted anywhere in the world, regional
differences play an important role in the effectiveness of combatting cybercrime. For example,
different kinds of content are criminalized in different countries, which means that material that can
lawfully be made available on a server in one country might be considered illegal in another (see
section 2 E, case 2.3). The issue of convergence of legislation is highly relevant, as a large number
Page 194 | Chapter 5 | § A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents