End Notes
Referenced in: § A. Multilateral
Instruments & Cross-border
Cooperation
1.
See generally Johnson & Post, supra §
2 A, note 31 (arguing that cyberspace
cannot be governed by laws that rely on
traditional territorial borders).
2.
“Dual criminality” (also known as
“double criminality”) refers, in the
context of international cooperation, to
a requirement that the act subject to a
request for extradition or MLA must be a
criminal offence according to the criminal
law of both not only the state making the
request, but also according to the law of
the state of which assistance is requested.
See, e.g., UNODC Cybercrime Study,
supra § 1 C, note 7, at 202.
3.
Amalie M. Weber, “The Council of
Europe’s Convention on Cybercrime,”
Berkeley Technology Law Journal, Vol. 18,
(2003), p. 426, at http://scholarship.law.
berkeley.edu/btlj/vol18/iss1/28
4.
See US Dept. of State, Bureau of
Counterterrorism, “Ch. 5: Terrorist Safe
Havens” (listing certain “safe-havens”),
in: Country Reports on Terrorism
(2014), at http://www.state.gov/j/ct/rls/
crt/2014/239412.htm.
5.
At the same time, it is useful to consider
the applicability of the United Nations
Convention against Transnational
Organized Crime (UNTOC), a global
instrument reaching almost universal
adherence with 187 States Parties,
which takes into account “cyber” crimes
committed by organized criminal groups.
6.
See UNODC Cybercrime Study, supra § 1
C, note 7, at 67.
7.
Some form of national cybercrime
legislation exists in 149 countries, either in
existing (137) or draft (24) form. See, e.g.,
appendix 9 C.
8.
See, e.g., Zahid Jamil, “Cybercrime
Model Laws: Discussion Paper Prepared
for the Cybercrime Convention
Committee (T-CY),” Council of Europe, (3
Dec. 2014), at https://www.coe.int/t/dghl/
cooperation/economiccrime/Source/
Cybercrime/TCY/2014/3021_model_law_
study_v15.pdf.
Page 218 | Chapter 5 | End Notes
9.
COMSEC, “Model Law on Computer
and Computer Related Crime,” in 2002
Meeting of Commonwealth Law Ministers
and Senior Officials: Kingstown, St Vincent
and the Grenadines, 18–21 November
2002, (London: Commonwealth
Secretariat,2003), at http://www.oecdilibrary.org/commonwealth/governance
/2002-meeting-of-commonwealth-law-mi
nisters-and-senior-officials/model-law-oncomputer-and-computer-related-crime
_9781848598188-16-en; COMSEC, “Draft
Model Law on Electronic Evidence,”
in 2002 Meeting of Commonwealth
Law Ministers and Senior Officials:
Kingstown, St Vincent and the
Grenadines, 18–21 November 2002,
(London: Commonwealth Secretariat,
2003), at http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/
commonwealth/governance/2002meeting-of-commonwealth-lawministers-and-senior-officials/
draft-model-law-on-electronicevidence_9781848598188-11-en;
UN Conference on Trade and
Development (UNCTAD) and Eastern
African Community, “Draft EAC
Legal Framework,” (2008), at http://
repository.eac.int:8080/bitstream/
handle/11671/1815/EAC%20
Framework%20for%20Cyberlaws.
pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y; Common
Market for Eastern and Southern Africa
(COMESA), “Cybersecurity Draft Model
Bill,” (2011); ITU, “HIPSSA-Southern
African Development Community
Model Law on Computer Crime and
Cybercrime,” (2013); ITU, CARICOM
& CTU, “Model Legislative Text on
Cybercrime/e-Crimes and Electronic
Evidence,” (2010); ITU and Secretary
of the Pacific Community, Model Law
on Cybercrime, (2011). See ibid, for
selected examples of implementation of
non-binding multilateral instruments on
cybercrime.
10. Of these multilateral treaties, only the
AU Convention has not yet entered into
force, as, per Article 36 of the Convention,
the requisite threshold of fifteen ratifying
AU Member States has not been
achieved: to date, only eight Member
States have signed the AU Convention,
and none have ratified it. See “List of
Countries Which Have Signed, Ratified/
Acceded to the AU Convention,” African
Union, (1 Jun. 2016), at https://www.au.int/
web/sites/default/files/treaties/29560sl-african_union_convention_on_cyber_
security_and_personal_data_protection.
pdf.
11. UN Congress on Crime Prevention,
supra § 2 A, note 3, at 15, (discussing
recent developments in the use of
science and technology by offenders
and by competent authorities in fighting
cybercrime).
12. Budapest Convention, supra § 1 B, note
32, at Preamble. Nine non-Member
States of the CoE (Australia, Canada,
Dominican Republic, Israel, Japan,
Mauritius, Panama, Sri Lanka and the
United States) have acceded to the
Budapest Convention. See “Chart of
Signatures and Ratifications of Treaty
185,” CoE, at http://conventions.
coe.int/Treaty/Commun/ChercheSig.
asp?NT=185&CM=8&DF=&CL=ENG.
These countries were not all part of
the process when provisions of the
Convention were elaborated. A further
thirteen countries (Argentina, Chile,
Colombia, Costa Rica, Israel, Mexico,
Morocco, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines,
Senegal, Sri Lanka and Tonga), none of
which are Member States of the Council
of Europe, and none of which participated
in the Convention’s elaboration,
have been invited to accede to this
Convention.
13. See supra §§ 4 A & 4 B for a fuller
discussion of the issues of safeguards,
including due process issues, data
protection, and access to information and
freedom of expression.
14. Ibid. See also Budapest Convention,
supra § 1 B, note 32, at Art. 15.
15. Budapest Convention, supra § 1 B, note
32, at Art. 15.
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents