announced, the chain’s traffic, sales and stock value were immediately affected, with profits
falling by forty-six percent for that quarter. Target subsequently agreed to pay US$10 million
to settle a lawsuit brought by shoppers affected by the breach.
Since most ICT systems are usually shielded from unauthorized access, an intruder must penetrate
the security system. As such, many legal systems class hacking—simply on the basis of being
unauthorized access—as criminal in and of itself.9 The Budapest Convention, for instance, addresses
hacking by criminalizing “offenses against the confidentiality, integrity and availability of computer
data and systems” at large,10 and, more specifically, by targeting “illegal access”, understood as
“access to the whole or any part of a computer system without right”.11 Laws generally categorize
the offense as unauthorized entry into a protected ICT system, regardless of the offender’s
purpose.12 However, the Budapest Convention allows that further mens rea elements13 in addition
to intentionality and “without right” might be included, as State Parties “may require that the
offence be committed by infringing security measures, with the intent of obtaining computer
data or other dishonest intent, or in relation to a computer system that is connected to another
computer system”.14
Case 2.2: United States v. Marcel Lehe Lazar (USA)15
Defendant, Marcel Lehe Lazar, pled guilty to two of nine counts of an indictment that
included three counts of gaining unauthorized access to protected computers, having hacked
into email and social media accounts of some one hundred Americans, including family
members of two former US Presidents, a former US Cabinet member, a former member of
the US Joint Chiefs of Staff and a former presidential advisor. Lazar claims to have breached
Hillary Clinton’s personal email server,16 although there is no evidence to verify that claim.
Lazar was apprehended and tried in his native Romania, where he was found guilty on similar
charges and jailed for seven years.17 Thereafter, in a showing of international cooperation
among law enforcement authorities, he was extradited to the United States.18 The US District
Court for the Eastern District of Virginia sentenced him to a further seven years in prison.19
II. Unauthorized Monitoring
Just like hacking, unauthorized “monitoring”20 might target devices, data or both; when data is
targeted, it is often referred to as “illegal interception”. Such activity is typically done by using or
installing monitoring devices or software in the ICT system after having gained access to the system.
The physical world analogue is wiretapping. It bears noting that, while initial access to the system
Page 81 | Chapter 2 | § B. Criminalized Conduct
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents