matters from a jurisdictional standpoint, as many cloud service providers have centers around the world; as a result, jurisdictional disputes between the country where cloud service providers are registered and those where data is stored is growing. Moreover, as discussed, data is frequently fragmented, with parts and pieces not only in various places but in various countries. Once these logistical, storage issues are coupled with issues of data privacy (see section 5 B, below), these jurisdictional conflicts can cause intense disputes. Case 2.11: Microsoft Corp. v. United States (“Microsoft Ireland”) (USA)70 In connection with the provision of its email and cloud-based services, Microsoft required its subscribers to provide certain location information when requesting email and other services. That information was stored in data centers proximate to the location identified by the subscriber. Much of the metadata related to such subscribers (with the exception of certain communication content data) was stored in the United States. In December 2013, the US District Court for the Southern District of New York issued a search warrant on Microsoft authorizing US law enforcement authorities investigating drug trafficking operations to obtain communication data of users that had their data stored in datacenters outside the United States. Microsoft entered a motion to quash the warrant, claiming that the communication content of the concerned email accounts was stored in a data center located in Ireland, arguing that such communication content is beyond the scope of the warrant. On 25 April 2014, the US Magistrate Judge issued an order denying Microsoft’s motion to vacate the warrant, holding that “an ISP located in the United States would be obligated to respond to a warrant issued pursuant to Section 2703(a) [of the US Stored Communications Act (SCA)71] by producing information within its control, regardless of where that information was stored.”72 On 31 July 2014, the US District Court for the Southern District of New York affirmed the Magistrate’s Order.73 Microsoft appealed to the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. The case quickly became a hotly contested one. Private sector entities (including AT&T, Apple and Cisco) raised concerns that the warrant would have to their business environments in amicus curiae briefs; and digital rights groups said it would have been an unwarranted intrusion. On 14 July 2016, a three judge appellate panel ruled in favor of Microsoft, concluding that Congress did not intend that a warrant issued under the SCA to have any extra-territorial effect. The Government has petitioned for a rehearing en banc. Page 107 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents