on the site, he had sold this stake and was no longer involved in Silk Road. With regard to
the evidence that the state presented, the defense argued that government surveillance
of Ulbricht’s online accounts was overboard and amounted to a violation of defendant’s
constitutional, Fourth Amendment rights, which protects against undue search and seizure.24
It was further argued that evidence favorable to the defendant regarding corrupt officials had
been improperly suppressed and tainted the case and evidence.
Ulbricht appealed his conviction saying, “The court abused its discretion and denied Ulbricht
his Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights to due process, the right to present a defense, and a
fair trial by (A) precluding the defense from using at trial the evidence relating to DEA Special
Agent Carl Force’s corruption; (B) refusing to order the government to provide additional
discovery and ‘Brady’ material regarding corruption; and (C) denying Ulbricht’s motion for
new trial based on additional post-trial disclosures regarding Force and another corrupt law
enforcement agent involved in the Silk Road investigation.”25
While Ulbricht lost his appeal in May 2017,26 the arguments made are ones that might well be
raised by defendants charged with cybercrimes.
III. Budapest Convention & Due Process
A general discussion of multilateral and international agreements in cybercrime can be found in
section 4 B, below. While the Budapest Convention is discussed in more detail in that section, it is
worth noting here that the Convention is alone among multilateral and international instruments
in specifically addressing safeguards and due process issues. That said, the provisions of the
Convention show the inherent tension among information gathering and investigative powers and
requirements of due process. With regard to due process safeguards, the Convention has specific
provisions on (A) general conditions and safeguards, (B) expedited preservation of stored computer
date and search and seizure of stored computer data and (C) expedited preservation and partial
disclosure of traffic data and expedited disclosure of preserved traffic data.
A. Safeguards
Article 15 of the Budapest Convention provides, inter alia, that domestic law shall implement
“conditions and safeguards [... that] provide for the adequate protection of human rights and
liberties”. Although binding on its Member States, a treaty mechanism alone as a source of due
process is insufficient without local law implementation.27 To that end, Member States are bound by
the Convention to transpose implementing provisions into their national laws.
Page 175 | Chapter 4 | § A. Due Process
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents