Apart from having a grounding in international law, assuring respect for human rights in the
cybercrime context is a matter of good policy.2 Recent scholarship squarely identifies and makes
the link between advancing rights of privacy and expression in the ICT context, on the one hand, to
achieving development objectives, on the other.3 It is generally accepted that free speech facilitates
the creation of a so-called “marketplace of ideas”; in turn, free speech encourages growth, be
it commercial, intellectual, artistic or political.4 Balancing stakeholder interests of security and of
stability, on the one hand, and promoting human rights, on the other, is essential to promoting the
enabling “trust” environment needed for building a digitally interconnected cyber-society (see
section 4 A, above).5
Just as society has expanded into cyberspace, so, too, have authorities, and law enforcement in
particular, expanded into and taken advantage of technological developments. Law enforcement
and national security agencies need access to ICT, and therefore utilize “wiretapping” (and
similar targeted-surveillance techniques), call center data registry and other metadata reporting
measures to investigate criminal activity.6 While the use of any and all of these tools poses
certain privacy concerns, their deployment with appropriate safeguards, including the external
seeking of appropriate and independent authorization, has largely resulted in the building of
secure, commercially robust, internet-based societies where human rights still manage to flourish.
Fundamental principles of “legality”, “necessity” and “proportionality” feature in this debate and
in creating such a “trust” environment that is so central to building a robust cyber society (see
section 1 B, above).
One of the key drivers in the digital economy is the flow of data, much of which is personal data.
Indeed, the amount of that data has increased by an estimated ninety percent in the last few years.7
This trend has in part been fueled “big data” applications for monitoring and manipulating data.8
Big data refers to both structured and unstructured data which is both of such a volume and which
is also communicated at such a high rate that it is difficult to process using traditional database and
software techniques.9 Big data applications can be found in both the public and private sectors.
While probably most commonly associated with private sector applications (such as Facebook and
Google), it is conceivable that these same, big-data analytical techniques could be used in the
fight against cybercrime; if so, attention would need to be paid to the prospect of intrusions into
individuals’ privacy.
The issue goes beyond simply having and enforcing national laws protecting personal data. As is
the case with cyberspace in general, data flows (whether legitimate or not) are global. As such, in
order to be effective, privacy regimes need to both enable and further facilitate legitimate internet
usage, as well as to assure individuals’ rights in the case of combatting cybercrime.
I. Applicable International Law & Good Practice
Page 179 | Chapter 4 | § B. Data Protection & the Right to Communicate
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents