Accountability Principle: A data controller should be accountable for complying with measures which give effect to the principles stated above. Collectively, these international and regional instruments, as well as the principles and guidelines, provide a rich source of international good practice for how to balance security with data protection and privacy. The flexible, open and decentralized nature of the internet augurs in favor of a principles-based approach (with notion of proportionality at its core) that balances state interventions and intrusions with individual human rights. As the internet functions on the basis of the creation of a “trust” environment, it is essential that such considerations and be weighed openly. C. The Special Place for Anonymity Anonymity can be seen as an essential component of protecting privacy on the internet.39 Not infrequently, this same anonymity is also highly problematic for public safety, due in part to legal and technical reasons. Particularly in the digital context, those same basic human rights protections that make the internet such a compelling and exciting tool for development and social advancement can also lead to problems of authentication in general, and attribution— that is, the connecting of a criminal actor to the act perpetrated—in particular. From a technical perspective, encryption is perhaps the most obvious issue.40 From a larger, legal perspective, particular difficulties exist where there is a divergence of legal frameworks, especially in light of a still-evolving MLAT framework. The latter obstacle is in part overcome by shared adherence to multilateral instruments, such as the Budapest Convention, which, among other things, creates such a framework.41 The issue of privacy and data protection in the context of surveillance, especially “mass” surveillance, is a particularly thorny issue.42 While the topic of “surveillance”, generally, is beyond the scope of the Toolkit, surveillance is an important tool for law enforcement in investigating crime, including cybercrime. The technological advances that have enabled cybercrime to expand have also enabled expanded surveillance tools and methodologies. All of these developments have resulted in unresolved questions of what are, and how to define, the appropriate limits on the collection of data relevant to an investigation. III. The Right to Communicate The “right to communicate”, as already discussed, speaks to the complementary rights of “freedom of expression” and “access to information” (see section 1 C, above). Communication, one of the Page 186 | Chapter 4 | § B. Data Protection & the Right to Communicate Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents