Some areas for consideration in the next generation of international instruments follow:
Inclusion. To attract interest—and ownership—from all states, space needs to be created to
include them in the consideration of the instrument from an early stage.
Multi-stakeholdersim. Stakeholders have grown and diversified. In particular, in recognition of
the role that private sector actors increasingly play in the fight against cybercrime, effective ways
of encouraging cooperation with law enforcement should be explicitly addressed.
Incorporating lessons learned. Cybercrime is evolving. Cybercrime is evolving. Many of the
existing instruments may need modification or renewal. There is an inherent tension in any
instrument between being sufficiently flexible to accommodate evolving cybercrime, and being
too vague or general; each dimension may require different types of adjustment.
Overcoming persistent limitations in coverage. Perhaps related to inclusion, uptake of
membership in international instruments, despite the openness of the Budapest Convention
and the proliferation of regional and sub-regional instruments while growing, is still relatively
low.
National implementation. Joining any of the instruments is not in and of itself the ultimate
goal; it is only the starting point. What is really required, ultimately, is national domestication
of the terms of those instruments, and subsequent implementing and practicing those
requirements by appropriate authorities.
International instruments aggravate differences among states. Because of the variability
of implementation of national laws to reflect treaty-based obligations (that is, differences in
national laws), cooperation obligations in treaties may exacerbate different approaches. For
example, rights of the accused may vary from country to country, but MLA provisions may
require assistance, thus potentially facilitating abuses, especially in areas of dual criminality.
Safeguards. Not all the instruments provide safeguards for protecting due process (see section
4 A, above) and other fundamental rights, notably in matters of privacy and/or data protection
and of freedom of expression (see section 4 B, above).
II. Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties
This subsection first provides a (A) general overview of the nature and general aspects of MLATs,
and then (B) examines how these aspects are treated in multilateral instruments using the example
of the Budapest Convention’s MLA provisions.
A. General Aspects of MLATs
MLATs are agreements between two or more countries for the purpose of gathering and
exchanging information in order to enforce public or criminal laws. While binding multilateral
instruments provide an important basis for international cooperation,46 even non-binding MLATs
Page 199 | Chapter 5 | § A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents