Convention allows for coupling with other extradition treaties: where another extradition treaty
exists, the offenses of the Budapest Convention might be deemed extraditable offences under
that other treaty,81 thereby potentially expediting matters, especially with states not party to the
Convention.
Conclusion
The inherently transnational, cross-border nature of cybercrime has led to jurisdictional issues—over
the crime, the evidence and the alleged perpetrators—that require international cooperation if
they are to be overcome. The most effective and efficient means of doing so is through formal
instruments, as supplemented through informal mechanisms. There is a threefold lack that these
formal instruments attempt to overcome, namely: lack of criminal laws, lack of procedural powers
and lack of enforceable MLA provisions.82 The three major means for filling-in these gaps comes
through cyber-specific multilateral MLATs, more general MLATs and extradition treaties.
The most comprehensive and influential cyber-specific instrument is the Budapest Convention. A
leading example of how to address the most urgent issues in the domain of cybercrime, its binding
nature on Parties has increased its efficacy and suits its aspirational goal of harmonization—an
ambition somewhat beyond interoperability—in this area. Moreover, the indirect impact of the
Convention has unquestionably been far-reaching, serving as a model for legislation, offering
general guidance and sparking substantial debate the world over. The Convention has done much
to further international cooperation, even among states that already enjoyed good relations.83
Notwithstanding its limitations, the Budapest Convention has many strengths, leading one
commentator to say that:
“[I]t is likely to remain the most significant international legal instrument in the
field for the foreseeable future.”84
Page 204 | Chapter 5 | § A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents